result #30565 - THE GENEVA CONVENTION, ARE AMERICAN SOLDIERS FOLLOWING THE RULES AS OUTLINED?

user ballots

choices : political :

THE GENEVA CONVENTION, ARE AMERICAN SOLDIERS FOLLOWING THE RULES AS OUTLINED?


[+] ballot by Barbara_Baby_Cakes
created Fri Apr 30, 04
What should be done? There are several American soldiers who have been court-marial from violating the rules of Geneva Convention against Iraqis prisoners of war. If it is proven that other countries are not in keeping with the rules of the Geneva Convention against American soldiers, should American soldiers go unpunished by their own government when it has been proven that they have treated POWs inhumanely? What is your opinion?

Americans should not engage in bad behaviors because others do. 9
No, two wrongs do not make a right. 2
YES 2
Terrorists aren't Following it, ... 1
If American soldiers are being treated poorly, they should do the same to the enemy. 0
Hey, this is war, one turn deserves another. 0
The American government should not punish its own. 0

Ballot #30565: has 14 total votes.
invite people to vote on this ballot!

Comment:

content @ BESTANDWORST.COM
smile bank:




similiar ballots:
102131. Weakening the Geneva Convention, will it put our troops at risk?
102424. Should the geneva convention be expanded to include terrorists?
77066. American Soldiers in Europe
33079. What are American soldiers doing with the people of Iraq?
98931. Do you think american soldiers would recieve any defense on here . . .
104409. Should American soldiers be on food stamps?
63416. Are American soldiers dying everyday for a lost cause?
75776. American soldiers raping an Iraqi woman?
102539. How many funerals of American Soldiers has George Bush Attended?
8718. When you think that American Soldiers will ever learn that guns are supposed to be pointed forward



email this ballot link to friends

COMMENTS:
Hey punk from Italy get a life, of course you forgot about the thousands of Iraqi's tortured by Saddam?

You need to know the Iraqi people are digging them up. Some still have ID's in their pocket.

If you ask a Iraqi who their more afraid of they will tell you another ARAB not an american.

I think this says it all.

by triple777bbb on Sat May 01, 04 9:02pm [+]

Yes, your stupidity spoke loud and clear :) Arrivederci!
by Barbara_Baby_Cakes on Sat May 01, 04 10:59pm [+]

I know you probably want to start an argument with this poll, but I don't think they should be treating POW's wrong. I'm all for the war in Iraq and Afganistan, but I think the American soldiers who were doing those things should be put in jai and millitary justice WILL do that. I also think the Britts are doing much worse and need to be punished to!

We are Americans, we are who we are because we are better then those who do these things! The marines doing those things should and will be put in jail.
by Toxacated on Sun May 02, 04 3:00pm [+]

I totally agree with you Taxacated - Wrong is wrong no matter who is committing the act(s) and who the act(s) are committed against.
by Barbara_Baby_Cakes on Sun May 02, 04 5:33pm [+]

They should be punished just like any soldier from any country who mistreat prisoners.
by mindy on Tue May 04, 04 2:24pm [+]

Depends, are the prisoners former members of a recognized national military or are they free-lancers, in which case, the Geneva Conventions do not protect them.
by CletuSlackedJawYokel on Tue Jul 27, 04 11:53am [+]

You will never find a single army involved in any conflict throughout history that followed the Geneva Convention standards appropriately in all categories. Such is war.
by jappy on Tue Aug 31, 04 12:57am [+]






About Us | Join Us | Privacy Policy | Contact
© 2002-2008 BestAndWorst.com All Rights Reserved