result #65040 - WHAT PUNISHMENT SHOULD BE GIVEN TO THIS CHILD?

user ballots

Popular Ballots
Recent Popular
Recent Votes

Best
Worst
Yes or No
Choices
What If
Prediction
Advice
Would You
Crime
Recommend
Quiz

TV & Movie
Music & Radio
Political
Science
Sports
Relationship
Techonology
Culture
Philosophy
Religion
Ethics
History
Food & Health
Fashion & Beauty
Crime
FanBase

Discussion
Bug Report

choices : ethics : WHAT PUNISHMENT SHOULD BE GIVEN TO THIS CHILD?

[+] serious ballot by LCD
created Wed Jan 19, 05

You are a kindergarten teacher. George, who is an aggressive little boy, started a fight with the school bully named Sam, accusing him of having his pencil. He rallies other kids to go beat Sam up, so he can get his pencil back. Now you know George is a scheming brat, because as other kids are beating Sam up, he calmly goes into Sam's lunchbox and eats his chocolate chip cookie. Now, after Sam received a good thrashing from all the George's friend, they go look for George's pencil in Sam's backpack. Surprisingly, there is no pencil. Everybody looks back at George, and George says, Hey my little brother Timmy told me George took it and put it in the backpack, I trusted Timmy to tell me the truth. Besides he argues, Sam was a bully anyway, he deserved a thrashing from everyone even if he didn't have his pencil. What should George's punishment be?

they should all be sent to the principal's office.	37%
they should be sold into slavery	25%
George should buy Sam a cookie and apologize	14%
George should be impeached for lying	14%
None, Sam deserved it, he is a bully.	7%
sam and timmy should be sent to the principal's office.	0%
George should be proclaimed the hero, Timmy is punished	0%

Ballot #65040: has 27 total votes.
invite people to vote on this ballot!

Comment:

content @ BESTANDWORST.COM

smile bank:

similiar ballots:
127399. What punishment is appropriate for a convicted child rapist?
94914. Is beating a child with a Bible a good child-rearing technique?
31403. What was the worst PUNISHMENT you've ever gotten when you were a kid?
69470. Reward and Punishment
72383. Racism or just punishment?
72808. YOu know when people say, that will be more punishment?
86719. What do you think this guys punishment should be?
92004. McKinney: What should her punishment be?
116183. Crime and Punishment
122654. Collective Punishment

email this ballot link to friends

COMMENTS:
i would have the class gather around and beat george and timmy. then i would lose my job, and go to prison for contributing to juvenile deliquency and physical child abuse, but it would be worth it, to teach the kids that life sucs.

by Iddyboop on Wed Jan 19, 05 5:24am [+]

This doesnt add up. how can sam be the bully when its clear that george is the bully? Bullies always have people around them thats why they get away with bullying! I would point out to the children that george is not to be trusted and haul him up in front of the class and make an example of him by humiliating him in front of his peers i would then spend time quietly with sam reassuring him that it wasnt his fault. as for the cookie and the pencil well thats just symbolic and has no real point in the issue! Although I would probably get sam a cookie and present it so all the children can see but thats pretty much an irrelevence!

by xxxxxxxx on Wed Jan 19, 05 5:55am [+]

Is this some sort of analogy to something else perhaps?

by xxxxxxxx on Wed Jan 19, 05 5:56am [+]

If I knew for a fact that Sam was a bully then I would give George a mild punishment.

by thc2883 on Wed Jan 19, 05 6:07am [+]

Even if sam was a bully letting george get away with lying and manipulation sends out the message that its ok to be a complete shit! What lcd neglected to mention was that sam goes to a different school and george invaded the school and therefore the police should be brought in because its a crime!

by xxxxxxxx on Wed Jan 19, 05 10:53am [+]

Moral of the story: Don't be a bully, because there is always a bigger bully with bigger baseball bat ready to clobber you.

by LCD on Wed Jan 19, 05 3:37pm [+]

Stick to creating web sites LCD your no good at morals!

by xxxxxxxx on Wed Jan 19, 05 3:56pm [+]

Most bullies are really cowards! I agree with mobsie on everything he said except the last little bit about LCD and thats only because i have no idea about his morals because i have never even met him.

by Kisty on Fri Jan 21, 05 12:27pm [+]

About Us | Join Us | Privacy Policy | Contact