=== Whether John McCain or Barack Obama, remember to register to vote! ===

result #98998 - HAS THERE BEEN TOO MUCH ALARMISM OVER GLOBAL WARMING?

user ballots

political :

HAS THERE BEEN TOO MUCH ALARMISM OVER GLOBAL WARMING?


[+] serious ballot by xxxxxxxx
created Thu Aug 03, 06
Matt Weaver
Thursday August 3, 2006
Guardian Unlimited


"Government and media organisations were today accused of undermining efforts to tackle global warming by using alarmist language that amounts to "climate porn".
The "apocalyptic" way in which climate change is often portrayed in the press and on government websites succeeds only in "thrilling" people while undermining practical efforts to tackle the problem, according to Labour's favourite thinktank, the Institute for Public Policy Research.

It analysed reports of climate change in 600 articles, 90 television adverts and news clips, as well as websites run by government and green groups.


A report on the project, published today, found that the issue was discussed in wildly divergent ways, and it argued that this meant the message to the public on climate change was "confusing, contradictory and chaotic".
It says that the most prevalent tone for the discussion was "alarmist" and this was not confined to the tabloid press. It even cited a video on climate change produced by the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs.

Articles cited included one in Dazed and Confused, which said "We're heading for dodo status", and a piece in the Financial Times, which said "Think of being a canoe drifting downstream, then recognising too late that you are about to go over a waterfall".

The report said that such "sensationalism... serves to create a sense of distance from the issue".

It argued: "Alarmism might even become secretly thrilling - effectively a form of 'climate porn' rather than a constructive message. All of this serves to undermine the ability of this discourse to bring about action."

The report also contrasted such messages with discussion of the small practical steps, such as turning off lights, that people are encouraged to take to tackle global warming.

It said the tone of discussion had caused the public to question whether small actions on their part really had the potential to make a difference to events on such an "epic" scale.

The report, entitled Warm Words, urges the government and campaigners to stop using alarmist language and start prompting environmentally friendly behaviour "as a brand that can be sold".

Launching the report, Simon Retallack, the IPPR's head of climate change, said: "Currently, climate communications too often terrify or thrill the reader or viewer while failing to make them feel that they can make a difference, which engenders inaction."

He added: "Government and green groups should avoid giving the impression that 'we are all doomed'. The focus should be on the big actions that people can take to address climate change, like switching to a hybrid car, fitting a wind turbine or installing cavity wall insulation, not just small ones such as turning down the thermostat or switching off the lights."

A spokesman for Defra said the report "makes a valid point" but he claimed that the government was campaigning to promote practical steps to tackle global warming.

He added: "This report is a useful addition to the debate. The department have been working hard to change people's attitude at the grassroots level and we are moving now to changing behaviour and not counselling despair." "

Do you agree with the above article that there has been too much alarmism and that it is detrimetnal?




No 40%
Yes 33%
Yes, too much alarmism 14%
Not enough you little dipshits 11%

Ballot #98998: has 42 total votes.
invite people to vote on this ballot!

Comment:

content @ BESTANDWORST.COM
smile bank:




similiar ballots:
111269. How will global warming deniers react if Bush flip-flops on global warming?
82061. Global Warming..
76709. How big of a problem is global warming?
100120. Is global warming real???
100816. What do you think about people who tell you "We Cause Global Warming!!"?
112013. Global Warming caused by the Sun?
112019. Does anybody else here think that global warming is AWESOME?
112065. What are the REAL causes of global warming?
118385. Should I take advantage of global warming
119251. The PositiveThings About Global Warming...



email this ballot link to friends

COMMENTS:
Voted : Yes
I don't hear anyone bitching about it in the winter time. IC_tune

by _Beelzebubba on Thu Aug 03, 06 9:41am [+]

Voted : Yes
To a certain degree yes there has been a bit of alarmism in Global Warming discussion.There is no doubt in my mind that Global warming exists however I am not sure if man is causing it or if we can even stop it.
by Corrupt on Thu Aug 03, 06 12:39pm [+]

"Climate porn"?
by Applerod on Thu Aug 03, 06 4:43pm [+]

Yes, but of course that seems to be acceptable these days. When gore openly admitted that he was exaggerating the threats of global warming in his film and in speeches many people cheered him for doing what was necessary to bring attention to this.

Seems it's ok to lie so long as it's for the right cause.

By the way, did you know that global warming has been shown to cause syphilis?
by herzog on Thu Aug 03, 06 5:29pm [+]

maybe it should be called "climate change" so you tots who have such a Problem with "global warming" and the whole "don't blame the 6.6 billion stinking apes" kick could start to think of it realistically. 20 years from now the most God-fearing, ego-MANiac fatties will still be denying we can have any affect on this planet.. and who cares anyway when we have Heaven to look forward to, right? :p
God cares more about each one of you than he does about the pretty planet, so sleep well!
I love that even considering the one environment is still a political issue, I trust it will never change!
by Jyl on Thu Aug 03, 06 6:41pm [+]

Voted : Yes, too much alarmism
Yes. Clearly.

A week and a half ago the temp was 112, then a week later it was 74.

That is a drop of 38 degrees in one week. Taken in that way it is indicative of a catastrophic weather change.

Then this week the temp has run 10-15 degrees F below the average temp for years past.

Isn't that indicative that, at least in this area, we are moving very quickly into an ice age?


I heard, that today, temps in Boston dropped more than 20 degrees F in a couple of hours.

Oh no. The sky is falling.
by Noblese_Oblige on Thu Aug 03, 06 7:08pm [+]

Voted : Yes
perhaps - though i think that it is inevitable that given a controversial issue - extreme views will be presented - to get attention, to make a point. Unfortunately sometimes this detracts from the validity of an argument. If only we were all thinking people that could see through the hype and grasp the real issues at hand. Our weather patterns are changing, our use of fossil fuel is affecting that change, and can we really afford to continue on the course we are on? And what effective and realistic changes can we put into practice? We can and should look past the sensationalism and ask what is the core of truth that lies within this debate. But the older i get the more i recognize the complacent stupidity of my fellow humans (sorry folks......) and i wonder if there really is any hope for the future. So then maybe neurosis is a blessing in disguise in that i also still believe that somehow, someway we will fumble through.
Who's responsibility is it anyway - to evaluate the alarm - those that present it, or those that receive it?
ok simply put - too much alarmism is detrimental - but as thinking humans - can we not recognize that without totally disregarding the cause behind the alarm?
by lightreaper on Thu Aug 03, 06 7:08pm [+]

we will not
by Jyl on Thu Aug 03, 06 7:14pm [+]

Yes, because the change in temperature has never been proven to be anything more than a natural climate change. 1 degree over the last 10 years folks, that's it, 1 degree.
by jappy on Fri Aug 04, 06 5:28am [+]

IC_clown Perfect
by Jyl on Fri Aug 04, 06 6:35am [+]

Voted : Yes
The fact is that Earth has had ice ages, and then subsequently warmed. All that happened before man was the predominate species on the planet. If "global warming" is occurring... there is simply not enough evidence to prove whether it's a natural occurance or not. The Earth is millions of years old, and man only has detailed weather/climate records that go back 200-300 years. Give or take a century or two.
by xxxxxxxx on Fri Aug 04, 06 7:59am [+]

What's "Natural" about 6.6 billions apes and their stinky metal cities replacing the forests with trash?
by Jyl on Fri Aug 04, 06 8:32am [+]

Jyl: what's natural about global warming following a period of global cooling? Well, everything actually, it's been happening in predictable cycles for as long as the earths been around.

So why make it seem unnatural?
by herzog on Fri Aug 04, 06 10:31am [+]

I asked what is natural about the affect 6.6 billion people are having, not about the weather fluctuations you'll cling to until you die :)
lightreaper summed up this response and the reason so many people will never be able to face the truth.
by Jyl on Fri Aug 04, 06 10:51am [+]

Voted : No
Let's see what you have to say when you can't breathe the stuff. And, if it interests anyone, Pat Robertson is now in the alarmist camp. Scared yet, anyone?
by Truthseeker013 on Fri Aug 04, 06 1:29pm [+]

I could understnad the cries of paranoid alarmist if we had more than one planet to live on.
by Truthseeker013 on Fri Aug 04, 06 1:30pm [+]

The question isn't whether global warming exists and/or whether it effects the Earth's weather/climate.

The real question should be: If global warming is occurring... are humans causing it?

The answer to that question is simple. There simply isn't enough information available to determine whether humans are causing global warming.

Accurate weather history only goes back approximately 200 years. The Earth is millions of years old. The Earth has gone through ice ages and subsequently warmed, and there were no humans causing the global warming then. The data isn't there.
by xxxxxxxx on Mon Aug 14, 06 7:05am [+]

(pasting that on every ballot about the climate has not made it true, it's just made it more pitiful and desperate)
by Jyl on Wed May 23, 07 6:24pm [+]






About Us | Join Us | Privacy Policy | Contact
© 2002-2008 BestAndWorst.com All Rights Reserved