=== Whether John McCain or Barack Obama, remember to register to vote! ===

IS IT INSULTING TO CALL A BLACK PERSON 'ARTICULATE'?

user ballots

culture :

IS IT INSULTING TO CALL A BLACK PERSON 'ARTICULATE'?


[+] ballot by mojo
created Wed Sep 20, 06

According to Eugene Robinson, Washington Post Columnist, it is.

Here is an exerpt from his rant on last night's CBS Evening News new segment 'Free Speech':

"{I don't support Condoleeza Rice} until I hear some commentator describe her as, quote, articulate, which is code for a black person who speaks standard English. Excuse me, you were expecting the Secretary of State to be inarticulate?

"That's when I get this involuntary twitch and I want to defend Condoleezza Rice — when she's patronized, the way black pioneers in all walks of life have been patronized. Look, it may be wrongheaded foreign policy, but Condoleezza Rice is making it.

"Condoleezza Rice is a major, major player in this administration. So call her whatever you want, but don't call her a token or a puppet. And please don't call her 'articulate'."

* * * * *
This strikes me as absurd. Yeah, Eugene, we'd EXPECT George Bush, the President, to be articulate too, but he ain't. In fact, he's often described as 'inarticulate'. Is that 'code' for 'dumb honky'??

Please. Will we soon be too afraid to utter a single word for fear of offending someone who takes it the wrong way, or who thinks it's non-PC?

Is it right or wrong to use a term like 'articulate' to describe an African American?

NO, it's not wrong. It is a word that happens to describe her perfectly.
YES, it's wrong, how DARE they call Condi articulate??
Yes. Persons should be considered articulate until proven otherwise.
Yes. Being "articulate" is frowned upon and not considered cool in certain cultures.
I'm not sure. It does seem latently racist


Ballot #102218 : SEE RESULTS

Comment:

show your vote with comment?

v 2.0 © BESTANDWORST.COM
smile bank:










COMMENTS:
Voted : NO, it's not wrong. It is a word that happens to describe her perfectly.
I saw that, I don't see it as being wrong, she is articulate and The President is not.
by oh_what_a_relief on Wed Sep 20, 06 6:58am [+]

Voted : NO, it's not wrong. It is a word that happens to describe her perfectly.
But I've never heard that word used to describe a black person before.
by RunsWithScissors on Wed Sep 20, 06 7:04am [+]

Voted : NO, it's not wrong. It is a word that happens to describe her perfectly.
I suppose anything could be used as an attack/offense/ back-handed compliment, but I am just not seeing that, in this case.
by Cathexis on Wed Sep 20, 06 7:11am [+]

Voted : NO, it's not wrong. It is a word that happens to describe her perfectly.
I didnt see this interview but he sounds like a knob with a chip on his shoulder.
by Searchlight on Wed Sep 20, 06 7:11am [+]

'Yes. Persons should be considered articulate until proven otherwise.'

What do you mean? Sounds like that should be a no answer??
by mojo on Wed Sep 20, 06 7:57am [+]

Voted : Yes. Being "articulate" is frowned upon and not considered cool in certain cultures.
He'd have had more credibility if he would have made that statement wearing some tap shoes and white gloves. IC_tune
by _Beelzebubba on Wed Sep 20, 06 8:50am [+]

I love it when those black babes get all articulate. It gives me the jungle fever! But it really makes the juice run down my leg when they get erudite!
by cranky on Wed Sep 20, 06 9:27am [+]

You're taking the quote out of its cultural context. CHRIS ROCK on Colin Powell "speaking well" said it best:

"Whenever Colin Powell is on the news, white people give him the same compliments: 'How do you feel about Colin Powell?', 'He speaks so well! He's so well spoken. I mean he really speaks so well!' Like that's a compliment, sh*t. 'He speaks so well' is not a compliment, okay? 'He speaks so well' is some sh*t you say about retarded people that can talk. What do you mean he speaks so well? He's a fuc*ing educated man! How the fu*k you expect him to sound, you dirty motherfuc*er? 'He speaks so well.' What are you talking about? What voice were you expecting to come out of his mouth? 'Imma drop me a bomb today', 'I be Pwez o dent!'."
by elvislennon on Wed Sep 20, 06 9:38am [+]

Voted : NO, it's not wrong. It is a word that happens to describe her perfectly.
Shes as articulate as a lorry...
by Steelhamster on Wed Sep 20, 06 9:39am [+]

Voted : NO, it's not wrong. It is a word that happens to describe her perfectly.
Her skin colour is of no consequence. (Rather, her skin colour SHOULD be of no consequence.) (But, to some, sadly, it is.)
by Black_Lava on Wed Sep 20, 06 9:58am [+]

Although I hadn't considered it before, I do think Mr. Robinson is right. We do sometimes use "articulate" as a code word for a Black person who uses standard English. Is it racist to do so? I suppose the argument could be made that it is latent racism. How do we avoid it? I don't know. I heard a White football player once described as having "an uncluttered mind." This is code for dumb, I'd say, but no one accused the speaker of racism.
by margaret123 on Wed Sep 20, 06 11:31am [+]

Voted : NO, it's not wrong. It is a word that happens to describe her perfectly.
^ I wholeheartedly disagree. Articulate is a good word. Why should it be laden with connotation? What words / phrases are we going to make offensive next? Intelligent? Eloquent? Gifted with words?

IMO, it's wrong to put limits on our wonderful language (unless a racial slur is being used). Adjectives are our friends. Adjectives love freedom.
by mojo on Wed Sep 20, 06 11:50am [+]

I am often called 'special' by some members of the medical profession razz
by Steelhamster on Wed Sep 20, 06 11:57am [+]

Voted : I'm not sure. It does seem latently racist
But I cut off the part about latent racism. Being Black, I know that there are Blacks who can't talk their way out of a paper bag if you left the business end open and cut out the bottom. You all know what I speak of. You see the example almost daily on the six o'clock news, when something happens in an urabn neighborhood.

For myself, I'm *not* that terribly articulate in a verbal sense. Not because I'm not in command of the English language, but because I'm almost terminally introverted in person, extending to my phone skills. But I can see the point the man poses.
by Truthseeker013 on Wed Sep 20, 06 12:26pm [+]

Not too fond of it, mind you...
by Truthseeker013 on Wed Sep 20, 06 12:26pm [+]

One day, I *will* learn ho to use this keyboard, I promise...

I think that Mister Robinson could find a more apllicable subject to voice his opinion about. Poverty, health care, the lack of effective leadership we have in the world today, top to bottom. He must've slept his deadline.
by Truthseeker013 on Wed Sep 20, 06 12:28pm [+]

I hardly think Condi needs Robinson to "defend" her.
by Grumpy_Person on Wed Sep 20, 06 2:04pm [+]

i wouldn't call her that. she actually stammers and has a hard time putting words together.
by neothe1 on Wed Sep 20, 06 5:13pm [+]

like me
by neothe1 on Thu Sep 21, 06 4:58pm [+]






About Us | Join Us | Privacy Policy | Contact
© 2002-2008 BestAndWorst.com All Rights Reserved