user ballots
Login
Register
Add One
FAQ/Contact
Popular Ballots
Recent Popular
Recent Votes
Best
Worst
Yes or No
Choices
What If
Prediction
Advice
Would You
Crime
Recommend
Quiz
TV & Movie
Music & Radio
Political
Science
Sports
Relationship
Techonology
Culture
Philosophy
Religion
Ethics
History
Food & Health
Fashion & Beauty
Crime
FanBase
Discussion
Bug Report
|
COMMENTS:
Voted : Yes, that is very odd
More than a little.
Voted : Does it matter?
We are all worm food in the end.
Voted : Does it matter?
I don't care what happens after I'm dead.
Voted : Does it matter?
I don't the dead mind.
Well! I don't think the dead mind. This was my comment before the cyber demons twisted it.
I didn't ask if the dead minded. I asked if the practice of burying everyone according to a minorities religious beliefs was odd, or normal.
I just dont believe its important, hence my answer
Voted : Yes, that is very odd
Wouldn't the cemetery be digging it's own grave, so to speak? Meaning that plot sales could plummet.
by MO_ on Mon Sep 25, 06 6:24pm
[+]
"All headstones at the 40-acre burial site will face northeast, enabling the dead to look over their shoulder toward Mecca, the manner prescribed for followers of Islam in the UK." Won't that give them stiff necks?
Voted : No, seems perfectly normal to me
If you don't want your loved one buried there, find another burial plot. Myself, I plan on having my ashes placed in a nave facing west, just to thumb my nose at the rest of the dead. Still, doesn't matter what any of us think on the matter. When you all get up there, you'll be mderately surprised to see that there's only one Deity, with a very long nameplate on Its Desk.
Voted : Yes, that is very odd
It seems strange to make a majority belief conform to a minority belief. In my point of view the cemetery would just be better divided into sections catering to different desires. A Muslim section that faces Mecca could be done. A Chinese section that uses the traditional shrines. And a Christian section that faces east. And etc.
^ To all the insensitives above Burying the dead has more to do with the people left behind than it does the person who died. The people left behind- loved ones, family of the dead, may feel strongly about what is the right way to pay tribute to the one they loved. Their emotions, even if somewhat overly sentimental, need to be considered.
Mr. Herzog: "Odd or normal"? Actually, you asked if it seemed "a little bizarre." I don't know what "normal" is for planting folks. I suppose if you deviate from the standard practice you could be odd or bizarre. My comment was merely to express that it seemed fairly silly to care.
margaret123- even if it is silly that family members of the dead care, the fact is that nonetheless that they care. If a small request of which direction it is to face will give them a little bit more peace of mind, I see no problem with fulfilling that, even if it does seem silly. For that reason, cemeteries should have different sections, in which there are different areas customed to different religious beliefs.
Does it matter? Personally not to me. But to some traditionalist Muslims and Christians, they may indeed care. And they should be allowed to care, and cemeteries should cater to both.
Voted : Does it matter?
Let's see ... standardizing a practice because: * It is important to one group, and * It is a non-issue for all other groups. IMO, one would have to be looking for something to whine about to get ones' panties in a bunch over this.
Geez, herz, if it bothers you so much, have them bury you backwards with no pants so your backside is facing Mecca.
Cathexis- "* It is important to one group, and * It is a non-issue for all other groups" - It says in the article that Christians prefer to have theirs face east. I've never heard about it... but apparently that's what that article said. Not sure myself. The article also said that Muslim leaders would like Christians to be buried the way that Christians would like as well. It is clear that both Muslims and Christians would like the other to be able to their burials in the manner that they like. There is no conflict. It is just a mere issue of this cemetery learning to cater to more than one set of tradition. Most cemeteries that have already adapted to multiculturalism, and provide different sections inside them- Muslim section, Christian section, a specific Catholic section in many cases, Jewish, Chinese, etc. I don't think the issue in this article was to make Muslims or Christians look bad. Both sides showed interest in the feelings of the other. The issue is merely that of cemeteries needing to adapt to multiculturalism so as to satisfy all groups- as has been done successfully in many other places that have longer been accustomed to multiculturalism.
What cath means is that it's an issue to a protected minority group and only opposed by evil white christians, so they can be ignored. That's a pretty standard line of reasoning. Imagine if they were to bury everyone facing east, even muslims, that would not be a 'who cares' type of question, the usual suspects would be up in arms about how this is unfair and discrinatory. It's just the usual rhetoric from the left.
|
|