search this site: search the web:
Best and Worst.com: Where the best can show their worst and the worst can show their best.

COMPARITIVE DEMOCRACY

user ballots

political :

COMPARITIVE DEMOCRACY


[+] ballot by funtastic
ACTIVE Tue Nov 14, 06 - Wed Nov 14, 07

The United States has non-compulsory voting. Basically, you do not have to vote in elections. Now, from a theoretical viewpoint, this is a sound rule, because the point of democracy is freedom of expression, in this case, the freedom of abstaining from voting. Here in Australia, however, not voting is penalized. Now, while this may not be a true to a traditional doctrine of democracy, it does ensure the most popular party wins, not just the one who was most popular AMONG VOTERS. I hope you recognized that distinction. Anyway, the point: Do you believe that the US system or the Australian system is more appropriate? /B4P/iAmWo/

US
Australia/ other compulsory-vote countries


Ballot #105348 : SEE RESULTS

Comment:

show your vote with comment?

v 2.0 © BESTANDWORST.COM
smile bank:









similiar ballots:
115869. Democracy: Best we can do?
116246. If this is democracy we don’t want it
116405. When Does Democracy End ?
16504. Is democracy, democratic?
94107. Still think US Democracy is not being undermined?
112609. Is democracy becoming associated with militarism?
23855. Is spreading Democracy though aggression ok
41429. America is not a democracy its a Republic!
66068. Who cares about DEMOCRACY in IRAQ?
66521. Best ways to spread Democracy?


COMMENTS:
Voted : Australia/ other compulsory-vote countries
Because it annoys me no end to hear the b*tching and moaning of the people who don't like the representation they get in Washington, only to learn that these "irate individuals" *never bothered* to go to vote when the chance to assert their opinions availed itself. Maybe if you educate them, then make them go, the system might work, IMO. Hell, might not, but anything's worth a try.

Boy, have I developed a potty mouth of late...
by Truthseeker013 on Tue Nov 14, 06 5:05pm [+]

The US voting system is better because in such a system as Australia citizens could be forced to vote/participate in a sham/fraudulent election.
by Krunkington on Tue Nov 14, 06 5:25pm [+]

Voted : Australia/ other compulsory-vote countries
I think it makes for a more representative body of government...if jury duty is mandatory, why not voting ? there should be fact and position papers certified by both parties to ensure voters know who they prefer to vote for...
by thesoothsayer on Tue Nov 14, 06 6:53pm [+]

Voted : US
You can't force people to use their rights.

They ought to, and they've no one but themselves to blame if they don't vote, but you can't force 'em.
by herzog on Tue Nov 14, 06 7:37pm [+]

Voted : US
It's a hard choice, but I agree with herzog on this one. It's the choice of the people to use their rights.

Also, if voting were made mandatory, wouldn't those who used to be non-voters merely vote straight-ticket, or vote for random candidates, or try to spell words out of the first letters of the candidates names? Making voting mandatory might make it seem to some more like a burden than a privelege.
by himself809 on Tue Nov 14, 06 8:28pm [+]

Himself809 is right, many people place Donkey Votes (blank). It's an issue I just cannot decide on. I lean toward the Australian system (I use Aus. becasue it's the one I live under, but many countries may have the same compulsory voting legislation). Even if some people put in blank/flawed votes, their is still going to be a higher turnout %. Then again, if choosing the 'least bad' candidate is Democracy in action, well that plain sucks.
by funtastic on Tue Nov 14, 06 8:41pm [+]

Voted : Australia/ other compulsory-vote countries
^ In the real world that is what democracy becomes. It's not perfect, but it's better than the other alternative systems.

I go for the Australian system. That way low voter turn out is not a problem (in Europe a lot of low-turn outs create a lot of problems- are expensive in trying tor esolve and so on). People should go to the polls. If they don't want to vote for anyone, they can make that absolutely clear by placing an empty ballot into the voting box.
by xxxxxxxx on Tue Nov 14, 06 9:52pm [+]

Unsure. The problem in the US is not 'voluntary voting vs mandatory,' IMO, but access to voting. It has traditionallly been in the interest of certain political parties to suppress the vote, so the system is structured in such a way as to make it inconvenient, at best.

If ballots were mailed to every eligible voter, for example, rather than asking them to stand in long lines on a Tuesday ... I believe participation would go up.

Making it compulsory ... I have mixed feelings.
by Cathexis on Wed Nov 15, 06 5:33am [+]

About Us | Join Us | Privacy Policy |
© 2002-2008 BestAndWorst.com All Rights Reserved