search this site: search the web:
Bestandworst.com - the only website created and run by a hippie hopped up on pain killers!

RSPCA CONDEMNS THE ISLAMIC COMMUNITY?

user ballots

RSPCA CONDEMNS THE ISLAMIC COMMUNITY?


[+] serious ballot by xxxxxxxx
created Wed Dec 20, 06

"Halal meat is being served to pupils in state schools without their knowledge, even if they believe the religious slaughter is cruel.

Parents have reacted furiously after being sent letters telling them their children's school dinners have been all-halal for 'some time'.

To conform with Jewish and Muslim religious tradition, animals are prepared for halal products by having their throats slit while conscious - a method many people believe is inhumane and which the RSPCA has condemned.

The meat was introduced at four schools in the Reading area with a high proportion of Muslim pupils. But parents of non-Muslim pupils - between 20 and 50 per cent of the schools' roll -say they were not consulted.

Coach driver Andrew Weston, 37, who has a son and daughter at St John's primary school, said: "We received a letter saying only halal meat was being served and had been for some time. I was shocked.

"The way the animals are killed for this meat is barbaric and cruel. Our children should have a choice."

Abdul Dean, ethnic minorities officer for the Christian Peoples Alliance, said: "Christian children should be given an equal chance to have non-halal meat. The school should have explained the situation to parents at the outset."

Last month, a head teacher in Rotherham caused an outcry when she said she intended to replace traditional turkey with halal chicken to create an 'integrated Christmas'. Jan Charters, head of Oakwood School, backed down after complaints by MPs.

A spokesperson for Reading Borough Council said: "The decision was taken several years ago. Schools thought it was the appropriate choice for their multi-cultural community. We are increasing options at the four schools by offering fish each day."

The other schools where only halal meat is served are New Town, Oxford Road and Alfred Sutton primary schools.

Earlier this year, an RSPCA pamphlet stated: "Muslim communities in the UK should review their slaughter practices. Research demonstrates that slaughter of any animal without stunning can cause unnecessary suffering.""

(SOURCE: TIL, UK)


Is it bigotry for the RSPCA (Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals) to criticise Islam the way it has?

Yes, that was bigotry, and should be condemned
No, they are being consistent by promoting animal rights, even where it clashes with Islam


Ballot #110545 : SEE RESULTS

Comment:

show your vote with comment?

v 2.0 © BESTANDWORST.COM
smile bank:









similiar ballots:
92388. Should the government intervene if all of the white people in a community segregate themselves from the rest of a community? If so, how?
97396. France condemns Israel's invasion of Lebanon?
118596. Zimbabwe's Mugabe condemns Bush and the West
27782. is your community bicycle friendly?
75342. Do you suppoert your GBLT community?
111328. Will the independence of Kosovo mean the International community is
130386. Which of these famous people were not community organizers?
130450. Do your co-workers think the 'Fridge' is community property?
77197. During the Calgary flood of 2005, where was the international community?
77985. Is there any benefit in making the black community successful?


COMMENTS:
Voted : No, they are being consistent by promoting animal rights, even where it clashes with Islam
Other than the fact that this was yet another case of minorities dictating their ways to the majority because of political correctness gone mad (such cases do not surprise me anymore), the fact that the RSPCA stood their ground on a sensitive mulitcultural issue did surprise me.
by xxxxxxxx on Wed Dec 20, 06 8:28am [+]

good response Socrates.. even though I am not a vegan I would hope the animals are killed with little to no suffering.
by Guest User from [168.221.143.68] on Wed Dec 20, 06 10:30am [+]

"Muslim communities in the UK should review their slaughter practices."

Of animals, or people?
by cranky on Wed Dec 20, 06 10:38am [+]

It's a shame they can't do something about hunting "for sport."
by skylab on Wed Dec 20, 06 1:29pm [+]

They have skylab, fox hunting is now banned in the UK.
by minni_the_minx on Wed Dec 20, 06 3:06pm [+]

There is a lot of nonsense going on about this issue. As they are pretty similar in methods, a properly done kosher or halal slaughter results in instantaneous death. Most experts in the field believe this method is more humane than the factory method used for general consumption. The standards for a slaughter being considered kosher are very high. This means that the person doing the slaughter must be very highly trained and use precision equipment. In the general method it is more like "git her done" instead of a focus on the quality.

These complaints pop up from time to time by various animal rights groups and then are debunked. Other animal rights groups believe if a slaughter must be done, kosher or halal is more humane.
by FiddleFaddleOnLSD on Wed Dec 20, 06 3:38pm [+]

Voted : Yes, that was bigotry, and should be condemned
I'm going to vote for bigotry because animal rights groups will pick on kosher and halal slaughter because these methods are used for minority groups. It is easier to go after the small fry and then work your way up to the bigger fish later - which is often the intention of many groups.
by FiddleFaddleOnLSD on Wed Dec 20, 06 3:41pm [+]

Voted : No, they are being consistent by promoting animal rights, even where it clashes with Islam
If it is consistent with their previous stances on animal slaughter then I see nothing wrong.

I don't necessarily agree with them, and as long as basic standards are adhered to I don't really care whether they use kosher or halal meat.

Although it does seem odd, these meats are usually far more expensive than others, seems like a waste of money to give everyone halal/kosher foods.
by herzog on Wed Dec 20, 06 4:15pm [+]

About Us | Join Us | Privacy Policy |
© 2002-2008 BestAndWorst.com All Rights Reserved