CANADIAN MUSLIMS CLAIM HUMAN RIGHTS ISSUE?

user ballots

CANADIAN MUSLIMS CLAIM HUMAN RIGHTS ISSUE?


[+] ballot by aya
created Wed Mar 07, 07

TORONTO (Reuters) - Canadian Muslims may launch a human rights complaint against soccer's governing body after a Quebec referee ordered an 11-year-old girl to quit a tournament for refusing to remove her hijab.

The Canadian Council on American-Islam Relations said the Federation Internationale de Football Association (FIFA) was sending a mixed message on its rules, given that its own Web site includes pictures of women wearing the hijab, a scarf that covers the head and neck.

"If FIFA does not provide a clear position on the right of women to wear the hijab in competition we will look at the possibility of filing a human rights complaint on behalf of Muslim women who want to play soccer, and not be persecuted for practicing their beliefs," said executive director Karl Nickner.

The 11-year-old girl, Asmahan Mansour, was ordered off the field by a Muslim referee during an indoor soccer tournament in the Montreal suburb of Laval, Quebec, on February 25 after refusing to remove her hijab.

FIFA spokesman Pekka Odriozola said it was up to regional and national associations to decide how to interpret soccer's Law 4, which says a player must not "use equipment or wear anything that is dangerous to himself/herself or another player."

"But each match official must decide how to apply the rules," he added.

The law, as displayed on FIFA's Web site, also says "modern protective equipment such as headgear, facemasks, knee and arm protectors made of soft, lightweight, padded material are not considered to be dangerous and are therefore permitted,"

Odriozola could not explain why the Web site included photos of players wearing the hijab.

"(The International Football Association Board) determined last weekend that anything related to players equipment is covered under Law 4 of the rules of the game," he said. "In official matches the laws of the game have to be applied."

That seems like foul play to Nickner of the Canadian Muslim group.

"FIFA backed the decision to support the Quebec referee in prohibiting a player from wearing the hijab," he said. "Yet the FIFA Web site shows pictures of women players wearing a hijab."

This is not the first incident involving soccer players ejected from a game for wearing religious headgear in Canada.

In 2005 a Sikh player was told to remove his patka head covering at a soccer tournament in Langley, British Columbia, prompting the cancellation of several games.

After that incident, the president of the B.C. Soccer Association said that there were no rules banning religious headgear from the sport.

Other Canadian provinces, including Ontario, also allow women players to wear the hijab.

-----
Is this kid being persecuted for her beliefs?

yes
no


Ballot #112851 : SEE RESULTS

Comment:

show your vote with comment?

v 2.0 © BESTANDWORST.COM
smile bank:









similiar ballots:
94799. Are Economic and social rights as valid in terms of human rights as political and civil rights?
103403. Muslims now claiming exclusive rights to the cube
85274. Who Wrote The First Declaration of Human Rights?
118574. Which violation of human rights outrages you more?
105552. In it's 6 months of existence the UN Human Rights Council has . . .
115110. Should the protection of human rights be an international priority?
96052. Which 4 countries opposed THE CREATION OF THE NEW HUMAN RIGhts council?
103405. Zionist group falsely claims Muslims claiming exclusive rights to the cube
112647. Asians declare cultural traditions are more important than human rights?
104078. Mexico drafts resolution criticizing border fence at UN Human Rights Counci


COMMENTS:
Voted : no
I don't quite see how this is a human rights issue. She's not being persecuted and killed for wearing the hijab. This is such a little thing.
by aya on Wed Mar 07, 07 12:31pm [+]

How can the hijab be concidered equipment that is dangerous to himself/herself or another player? If anything it only makes things safer (just ask Ala).
by ClosetIguana on Wed Mar 07, 07 12:34pm [+]

CI, yeah, I wondered about that too, but I don't think this quite qualifies as human right issues.
by aya on Wed Mar 07, 07 12:37pm [+]

Voted : yes
Human rights can erode, one small step at a time.

How can you ban someone from wearing something that is featured on players on your own website?

And, clearly, a scarf is not dangerous.

The ruling belies common decency and common sense.
by cranky on Wed Mar 07, 07 12:57pm [+]

But she's not really persecuted for her religion, is she? although the decision is in poor taste.
by aya on Wed Mar 07, 07 12:59pm [+]

how can you breathe with that thing on?
by LCD on Wed Mar 07, 07 1:47pm [+]

through your nose, lcd.
by neothe1 on Wed Mar 07, 07 1:52pm [+]

Voted : no
Isn't this part of the uniform code? There can be no sport without rules...

Except for maybe hunting. _Beelzebubba_Dick
by _Beelzebubba on Wed Mar 07, 07 2:39pm [+]

Voted : no
I see it as being about the same as a Christian not being allowed to wear a necklace with a cross on it. It's for the safety of the kid.

To me, not allowing Muslim girls to wear a hijab while playing soccer seems to be for the same reason that refs like to have backetball players tuck their jerseys in; tucking a jersey in makes it much more difficult to accidently (or intentionally) grab and potentially injure somebody. Both are stupid, overprotective rules, but hey, safety first, right? :P
by himself809 on Wed Mar 07, 07 3:57pm [+]

But having pictures of Muslim girls playing soccer in hijabs is misleading.
by himself809 on Wed Mar 07, 07 3:58pm [+]

I didn't know a hijab was dangerous.
by skylab on Wed Mar 07, 07 6:50pm [+]

Muslims should just be happy they're not getting beat down on a daily basis, and shut their yap traps.
by Guest User from [24.4.250.239] on Wed Mar 07, 07 10:38pm [+]

Voted : no
But FIFA needs to be clear on what's allowed or not in the pitch.
by seamus on Thu Mar 08, 07 1:22am [+]

The irony is that it was a Muslim ref that order her to remove the hijab or quit the tournament. 017
by ClosetIguana on Thu Mar 08, 07 5:10pm [+]

Voted : no
The fact she was ordered off the field by a Muslim referee would seem to suggest that the motivation was not religious but rather a result of perhaps an overzealous personal interpretation of 'Law 4'; though I'm really not sure how a head scarf could be considered dangerous, unless it wasn't properly fastened and was flying up in the girl's face, distracting her. (One would also hope that the scarf was of a muted color--possibly a team color--so it wasn't distracting to the other players.)

FIFA should just make some concrete decision on the wearing of headgear: hijab, yarmulke, bandana, or otherwise. This way it won't be open to interpretation.
by Applerod on Fri Mar 09, 07 1:35am [+]






About Us | Join Us | Privacy Policy | Contact
© 2002-2008 BestAndWorst.com All Rights Reserved