user ballots
Login
Register
Add One
FAQ/Contact
Popular Ballots
Recent Popular
Recent Votes
Best
Worst
Yes or No
Choices
What If
Prediction
Advice
Would You
Crime
Recommend
Quiz
TV & Movie
Music & Radio
Political
Science
Sports
Relationship
Techonology
Culture
Philosophy
Religion
Ethics
History
Food & Health
Fashion & Beauty
Crime
FanBase
Discussion
Bug Report
|
COMMENTS:
Voted : no
I don't quite see how this is a human rights issue. She's not being persecuted and killed for wearing the hijab. This is such a little thing.
by aya on Wed Mar 07, 07 12:31pm
[+]
How can the hijab be concidered equipment that is dangerous to himself/herself or another player? If anything it only makes things safer (just ask Ala).
CI, yeah, I wondered about that too, but I don't think this quite qualifies as human right issues.
by aya on Wed Mar 07, 07 12:37pm
[+]
Voted : yes
Human rights can erode, one small step at a time. How can you ban someone from wearing something that is featured on players on your own website? And, clearly, a scarf is not dangerous. The ruling belies common decency and common sense.
But she's not really persecuted for her religion, is she? although the decision is in poor taste.
by aya on Wed Mar 07, 07 12:59pm
[+]
how can you breathe with that thing on?
by LCD on Wed Mar 07, 07 1:47pm
[+]
through your nose, lcd.
Voted : no
Isn't this part of the uniform code? There can be no sport without rules... Except for maybe hunting.
Voted : no
I see it as being about the same as a Christian not being allowed to wear a necklace with a cross on it. It's for the safety of the kid. To me, not allowing Muslim girls to wear a hijab while playing soccer seems to be for the same reason that refs like to have backetball players tuck their jerseys in; tucking a jersey in makes it much more difficult to accidently (or intentionally) grab and potentially injure somebody. Both are stupid, overprotective rules, but hey, safety first, right? :P
But having pictures of Muslim girls playing soccer in hijabs is misleading.
I didn't know a hijab was dangerous.
Muslims should just be happy they're not getting beat down on a daily basis, and shut their yap traps.
Voted : no
But FIFA needs to be clear on what's allowed or not in the pitch.
The irony is that it was a Muslim ref that order her to remove the hijab or quit the tournament.
Voted : no
The fact she was ordered off the field by a Muslim referee would seem to suggest that the motivation was not religious but rather a result of perhaps an overzealous personal interpretation of 'Law 4'; though I'm really not sure how a head scarf could be considered dangerous, unless it wasn't properly fastened and was flying up in the girl's face, distracting her. (One would also hope that the scarf was of a muted color--possibly a team color--so it wasn't distracting to the other players.) FIFA should just make some concrete decision on the wearing of headgear: hijab, yarmulke, bandana, or otherwise. This way it won't be open to interpretation.
|
|