ISRAELI SOLDIERS USE INNOCENT PALESTINIANS AS HUMAN SHIELDS

user ballots

ISRAELI SOLDIERS USE INNOCENT PALESTINIANS AS HUMAN SHIELDS


[+] serious ballot by cranky
ACTIVE Fri Apr 13, 07 - Wed Jan 06, 10

Israel's human shields draw fire

Human rights groups return to court over army's use of Palestinian civilians

Basem Maswadeh knew he was in trouble when an Israeli soldier pushed him into the barber's chair and reached for the clippers.
The humiliation of a shaved head - or, more accurately, having chunks of hair ripped out by the brutal wielding of the shears - was the start of an ordeal that culminated with Mr Maswadeh and two friends standing in a Hebron street as Israeli troops shot over their shoulders at stone-throwing Palestinians.

"The soldiers hid behind our backs as they pushed us forward," said Mr Maswadeh. "Then they put their guns on our shoulders and began shooting. We felt our eardrums burning, but when we tried to put our hands over our ears, they beat our hands away. The noise was terrible because the gun was right next to my ear."

The soldiers fired dozens of plastic bullets, using the three Palestinian men as shields, before the crowd dispersed.

In May, as Israeli human rights groups sought a supreme court order barring soldiers from seeking protection behind human shields after their widespread use during the army's assaults on Jenin and other West Bank cities, the military admitted the policy was illegal and said it would stop.

But human rights groups will return to court on Sunday to argue that the army has only ended such abuses selectively, and is in breach of court orders.

"The method is the same each time," says Israel's most prominent human rights group, B'Tselem. "Soldiers pick a civilian at random and force him to do dangerous tasks that put their lives at risk."

Mr Maswadeh's experience in Hebron followed a different pattern. He owns a barber's shop. Like many firms, it defies the Israeli curfew. That is how Hebron's Palestinians survive.

When an army patrol swept along the road on December 3, shopkeepers quickly brought their shutters down. But the soldiers wanted to know who was in the barber's.

"We were scared," said Mr Maswadeh. "When the soldiers pay attention to you, they always abuse you. We did not want to open the door."

So the four Israeli soldiers grabbed the owner of the neighbouring grocery shop, Bilel Abu Qwaider.

"They told me, 'We are going to break your bones and destroy your shop if you don't get your neighbour to open his door,'" Mr Abu Qwaider said. "They were pointing their guns at me and threatening to shoot everyone inside. I begged Basem to open."

The barber realised he had little choice. "There were five of us, and they took us one by one into the street and beat us," Mr Maswadeh said. "Then they brought us back in and a soldier ordered me to sit in the barber's chair."

"He grabbed the electric clipper and brought it very slowly down on my head. It was very painful. I was bleeding because he was ripping my hair out. I knew I was in trouble when I opened the door, but I never imagined this."

Word of the beatings at the barber's shop quickly spread, and a crowd began throwing stones at the soldiers. It was then that Mr Maswadeh and two friends were marched outside and used as shields as the soldiers fired into the crowd.

When the mob backed off, the incident took another strange twist.

"They took pictures of us. They took some pointing their guns at us, and some resting their guns on our heads. One of the soldiers had a picture taken of him using one of my friends as a chair," Mr Maswadeh said.

Human rights groups say the army only investigates when forced by publicity, and it rarely punishes those responsible for such abuses. They say the military's attitude to people in the occupied territories was exposed by the Israeli army chief of staff, Moshe Ya'alon, when in a newspaper interview he likened the Palestinians to cancer and said he was administering chemotherapy.

"There is no doubt a culture of impunity," said Ms Stein. "Soldiers are rarely charged. There are not many military police investigations. Soldiers can do what they want.

The message soldiers are getting is, 'Don't violate the law, but we won't do anything if you do, unless it's a severe case'. The message is blurred," she said. (Guardian)

* * * * * * * *

Do you think the practice of soldiers using innocents as human shields is on the same level as Muslim fighters hiding among the civilian population, a practice that is strongly condemned as immoral and barbaric by some people who are pro-Israeli?

Yes, it's very similar
No, it's different because Israel has the right to defend itself
There are similarities and differences


Ballot #113930 : SEE RESULTS

Comment:

show your vote with comment?

v 2.0 © BESTANDWORST.COM
smile bank:










similiar ballots:
105700. Why don't the Israelis utilize human shields?
97450. Israeli soldiers who were kidnapped
95239. Palestine uses children armed with toy guns to test vigilence of Israeli soldiers . . . .
90200. Does it anger you to watch The Patriot, when those British soldiers burn all those innocent people up in that church?
114679. What's up with the Brooke Shields Alphabet?
96112. Taleban use children as shields to fight British
76702. Funny, Not Funny: Brooke Shields shoving 5 full bottles of Ritalin pills down Tom Cruise's Throat
106286. Has terrorism benefited the palestinians?
106311. Can Israelis and Palestinians ever coexist peacefully?
111229. Is what Israel is doing to the Palestinians constitute apartheid?


COMMENTS:
by cranky on Fri Apr 13, 07 7:39am [+]

by cranky on Fri Apr 13, 07 7:46am [+]

The terrorists in the Gaza Strip and West Bank area uses their own civilians as shields too and far more often.
by UncleMax on Fri Apr 13, 07 8:25am [+]

no, it's different because the Israelis are using their enemies as shields and the Muslims are using their own people...which I prefer because the Muslims have vowed to kill me and the Jews just want to charge me double.
by spanky on Fri Apr 13, 07 8:30am [+]

^So that makes it okay for Israel - the nation with Western values - to use Palestinians as human shields, too?
by cranky on Fri Apr 13, 07 8:33am [+]

Voted : Yes, it's very similar
You better watch out. Ol' Abe Foxman will send his goons to pin a hate-speech crime on you. 012
by _Beelzebubba on Fri Apr 13, 07 9:32am [+]

Voted : Yes, it's very similar
Yes it is. Both sides need to stop.
by skylab on Fri Apr 13, 07 10:16am [+]

Beelz:

FiddleFaddle/TinCan is probably e-mailing him right now.
by cranky on Fri Apr 13, 07 11:12am [+]

I see clear field of fire/access to that evil Israeli soldier.
The poor downtrodden Palestinian "shield" is protecting a small part of the Israeli soldiers, left lower thigh muscle.
Still, I guess that counts.
by aplmac on Fri Apr 13, 07 2:51pm [+]

^Looks like TinCan can't reply since he's blocked from your ballots.
by skylab on Fri Apr 13, 07 6:50pm [+]

Voted : There are similarities and differences
cranky-

I am not going to be relativistic about this. This kind of thing is wrong when anyone does it. I condemn any Palestinian or Israeli that does this. But I have yet to see you cranky condemn Palestinians doing this? I will admit somewaht of an extent of similarity.

On the other hand, your source (The Guardian- which is left-leaning) says that officially this kind of thing is illegal under Israeli framework, the military admitted that it is wrong and that it should stop, human rights groups are actively in Israeli courts bent on reenforcing the Israeli laws, and there have been court orders attempting to stop it and punish those involved. Can't you see the difference?

And lastly, would you say this is done on a wider scale by Palestinians or by Israelis, and would you say that has something to do with the fact that it is illegal in Israel and there are Israeli human rights activists in Israeli courts attempting to reenforce Israeli rules so that such Israeli soliders, whom the military has explicitly condemned as wrong, are being attempted to be cracked down upon, discouraged and stopped? This, while in Palestine, you do not see Palestinian human rights activists free to speak in courts, nor cite any Palestinian laws that condemn this, nor do Palestinian militas explicitly declare this kind of thing wrong, nor is Hamas trying to crack down on, discourage or stop it, even though it is on a much larger scale of Palestinians doing it than Israelis?
by xxxxxxxx on Sat Apr 14, 07 5:14am [+]

Skylab:

TinCan is just one of FiddleFaddle's aliases. Why should I let him get around the block I have on his FiddleFaddle alias by using another alias?

He has smeared me on his Fiddle user page, as well as numerous other places in comments.

Plus, he's now creating guest user comments attacking users (not just me) that he then goes in and approves with one of his aliases.

In short, he's acting like a jerk.
by cranky on Sat Apr 14, 07 6:22am [+]






About Us | Join Us | Privacy Policy | Contact
© 2002-2008 BestAndWorst.com All Rights Reserved