search this site: search the web:
Welcome to our New Server! Stronger, faster, with 10% bodyfat!
.it may take about 24 hours to make sure everything got transferred here all right.

BYSTANDER EFFECT: WHAT CAUSES IT?

user ballots

BYSTANDER EFFECT: WHAT CAUSES IT?


[+] serious ballot by seamus
created Tue May 22, 07

This ballot is inspired by LCD's account of the death of a lorry driver by fire. Only two people tried to help the guy while the other automobilists just stood there watching (Bystander effect). It's hard to blame them because it was an extreme situation. Humans instinctively fear fire and no one is really prepared to face such circumstance.
But it's not always a life or death situation, and people still seem unable to assist those who need help. Today, one my way to work, an old man on crutches fell in the middle of the road and it took quite a while for the bystanders to help him get back on his feet (he obviously couldnt do it on his own).
What keeps people from helping others?

Fear
Indifference
Conformity
Assuming that others are more qualified to help
Comment
Register to submit choices


Ballot #115076 : SEE RESULTS

Comment:
Register to submit comments
You may still vote without registration

show your vote with comment?

v 2.0 © BESTANDWORST.COM
smile bank:









similiar ballots:
8026. Which is the worse effect of pot?
18215. Will Gay Marriage REALLY effect YOU?
59454. Questioning *Cause and Effect*
32746. What is your favorite guitar effect?
65050. Is anyone here familiar with the 'Asparagus Effect?'
72834. What is your favorite sound effect?
39685. Which of the following has the greatest effect on teen smoking?
122369. Has anyone had more of an effect on world history in the last 30 years...
39319. Do you worry about global warming ( greenhouse effect ) ?
41066. Does SPOILING your children negatively effect their development?


COMMENTS:
There's a paragraph missing from the old man story: He felt because a speeding car that past by him made him lose his balance. Some people crossed the street looking at the man but no one offered any help. Same thing for the drivers. When two men finally helped him (they came from the other side of the street) all the others insulted the speeding driver...
by seamus on Tue May 22, 07 6:09am [+]

Voted : Comment
There is a very well documented phenomenon called "diffusion of responsibility", which is most relevant in situations where helping someone would not place ones life or safety in danger. Basically it is the assumption that someone else will help the person in need of it. Unfortunately, when everyone is thinking this it's not difficult to see how it can be problematic.

There is the case of Kitty Genovese, a young woman who was stabbed to death walking from her car to her apartment at night (in 1964). In her long struggle (it was actually a series of stabbings which occurred during the course of 32 minutes) and screams for help, it became known that there were 38 witnesses in the apartment complex who were aware that a woman was being brutally attacked. She was screaming for her life. The number of people who called the police? NONE. That's 0/38. The first call came some minutes after the final stabbing, when her attacker was through raping her and fled.
Here's a particularly salient section of an article about the murder:
"Samuel Koshkin witnessed the attack from the window of the apartment he lived in with his wife. 'I saw a man hurry to a car under my window,' he said later. 'He left and came back five minutes later and was looking around the area.' Mr. Koshkin wanted to call the police, but Mrs. Koshkin thought otherwise. 'I didn’t let him,' she later said to the press. 'I told him there must have been 30 calls already.'"
by Applerod on Tue May 22, 07 1:49pm [+]

^ I'm building a spaceship and moving to Mars. Nothing that people do surprises me anymore. Adios dumbasses.
by nuckinfutz on Tue May 22, 07 2:34pm [+]

Voted : Comment
Sometimes people just make really lame excuses for inaction to fool themselves into believing that they're good people, the above case is a perfect example. They were supposedly worried about tying up the phone lines calling for help, if someone's already calling, it's YOU who won't be able to get through, not the person who's already calling! Dumbasses. Sometimes though, there is a legitimate element of danger, and it would take an unsual amount of courage to endanger one's own life to try to save another that might not even be saveable.
by nuckinfutz on Tue May 22, 07 2:41pm [+]

Voted : Indifference
Responsibility gets spread around, and everyone wants to let someone else go through the trouble of doing something.
by skylab on Tue May 22, 07 6:30pm [+]

About Us | Join Us | Privacy Policy |
© 2002-2009 BEST AND WORST dot com All Rights Reserved