search this site: search the web:
100% User contributed and administered website.

CAN WE CHANGE OUR MINDS?

user ballots

CAN WE CHANGE OUR MINDS?


[+] serious ballot by contragrain
ACTIVE Sun Aug 05, 07 - Mon Aug 04, 08

The psychologist William James is quoted as having said:
"If you can change your mind, you can change your life."
The idea for this ballot was actually spurred by a joke ballot. I'm glad I didn't raise these points there, as doing so may have been construed as an attack on the people focussed upon in the joke. In any case, it would have been at the very best tedious, disrespectful, and otherwise droll to refuse to laugh with those who laugh.
I see and hear a lot of people on bestandworst trying to "change the minds" of other folks on the site. (And I'm not referring to the joke ballot writer. He's actually quite cool about these things.) This is not an interactive dynamic exclusive to this site. From my personal perspective, it pretty much runs throughout the human experience.
Personally, I think it's a headtrip to try to change the mind of another human being.
The mind (brain) is probably the most difficult organ of the human body to change. Some say we cannot change our basic brain functions (ie personality, preferences) under any circumstances. Others say we can, that it has happened to them. Still others would answer, "and, why, praytell, would I want to?"
The original joke ballot was about lesbians; but, you could apply it to any genetic predisposition. Certainly there is so much more to any one human being than just that one characteristic. There are people with a genetic predisposition toward athletics who seem to be a good athlete without even trying. Some are happy to identify themselves as "JEANETTE" or "JIM" "the ATHLETE," and yet others (I have met them) who resent being categorized in such fashion. To them, they are much more than "just an athlete." They like disciplines which do not come easily for them. They claim to have changed their minds. Either way, the only person who can answer whether their mind can change is the person themselves. Not other people who share similarities with themselves (ie athletes, homosexuals, etc.) and certainly NOT people who identify themselves in certain other categories such as intellectuals or heterosexuals (especially if they scorn the first group with words like "dumb jock" or "(place politically incorrect epithet for homosexuals here)"
The kind of mind changing I'm talking about here goes to the root of the brain. So, I reiterate the question, "Can people ever CHANGE their MINDS?"

Yes, it can happen
No, it's an illusion.
The biggest problem is when others try to change your mind for you. Brainwash you.
other, see comment
SORRY, THIS POLL
IS NOW CLOSED.

Ballot #116744 :
Voting Finished : SEE RESULTS

Comment:

show your vote with comment?

v 2.0 © BESTANDWORST.COM
smile bank:









similiar ballots:
35036. Anyone remember Simple Minds?
98910. Winning Hearts & Minds
17739. What if you suddenly had the power to read minds?
66114. Are we winning hearts and minds in Iraq?
53188. Do we underestimate the capabilities of the minds of non-human animals?
77004. If you could manipulate people's minds, would you use your powers for good or evil?
112947. Legal Minds : Scalper's Search Engine - Legally liable?
106313. Can You Name The Songs About Change Or With The Word Change...
62089. Imagine if we had the supercool ability to change our own skin color, would you change you skin color to someone of the opposite race??
37136. Had you ever known anyone that had a sex change?


COMMENTS:
Voted : Yes, it can happen
Yes. It happens all the time, constantly. Your mind is not your brain. Your mind is not your hard wired personality. Your mind is your viewed conceptions about things, your ego. It is endlessly transforming, taking new ideas in, discarding ones you no longer respect or desire.
by forgetmenot on Sun Aug 05, 07 10:43pm [+]

^okay, maybe I should have asked, "can we change our brain function?" Can we soften the hard wiring? Maybe add a few new circuits in the electrical box?
by contragrain on Sun Aug 05, 07 11:13pm [+]

Voted : Yes, it can happen
I have to say yes to this, because I used to be rabidly pro-death penalty, my only opposition to the process being the length of time between sentencing and execution. It wasn't until I witnessed my second execution, of the man who murdered my fiancee, that I began to realize that, at the end of the day, this guy wasn't atoning for anything with his death, that, if anything, he was getting a free pass on having to deal with the consequences of his actions. When he killed my fiancee, he effectively killed her entire family, because her sister died a few years later of cancer, and she barely made the effort to fight the disease, ebign so heartsick at Kay's death, and their father became nothing more than a shell of his former self. Now, when dealing with capital murder, I'd prefer the expedient of forcing the killer to relive the last moments of his/her victim's life in perpetuity.
by Truthseeker013 on Mon Aug 06, 07 6:28am [+]

Voted : other, see comment
Truth, i'm so sorry that happened :(

*big hug*

PP most murderers regret murdering, they can't change themselves because it's usually a mental problem.

Most, not all, but take Henry Lee Lucas for example. He cried about what he was and the fact that he couldn't change, but not until he saw the light, seriously, he saw a light and supposedly God spoke to him in his cell and told him that if he confessed everything he would be forgiven, so he did.

Not to say he could control himself and not kill again if he was released!

He told them before his first conviction of murder that he was going to kill again. He was remorseful. He is one of the MANY cases that suffered so much as a child that his brain was starved literally! Brain damaged and starved from being beaten with boards by his mom and not getting any nutrients as a child :(

Good old Henry Lee! ;)



About the brain changing, since most of your violent problems are due to deficiency and damage to the brain there isn't much you can do. Temporal lobe lesions cause violence. The front temporal lobe is the one that affects the persons mental stability, i think most violent of those patients have schitzophrenia and that frontal lobe being damaged causes them to have violent Schitzophrenia. don't confuse that with paranoid, big difference, a paranoid shy's away from people!

I don't know about change, except for what i read...i suppose there's a chance for many crack babies to grow up to be killers, and abused and starved kids...we can only hope that kids eat healthy and aren't abused or else i think it's too late.
by socal_sweetie on Mon Aug 06, 07 11:31am [+]

Voted : Yes, it can happen
Truthseeker013, I'm sorry to hear about your experiences and tragic misfortunes...I believe as people age they may or may not change their views on some things and on others, never change, in fact it's more or less how one reacts to the pros and cons of any given subject...some reject anything which may give credence to an opposing view and others adjust their conclusions based on available data...contragrain: I have a hard time "comparing altheletes/abilities with homosexuality because in everyones mind they know they are the product of a heterosexual encounter, not that it changes anything, it's just an irrefutable fact...I know my ballot could be considered insensitive but it was not meant to suggest anything of that sort actually happening...at the time when I was making it I thought it was humorous...and I wish to extend an apology if I offended anyone...reference ballot #116740
by thesoothsayer on Mon Aug 06, 07 3:53pm [+]

Voted : other, see comment
Only with great difficulty
by skylab on Mon Aug 06, 07 9:56pm [+]

Voted : The biggest problem is when others try to change your mind for you. Brainwash you.
but, yes, I believe it can happen. I've seen it among both athletes and homosexuals, athletic homosexuals, and non-athletic homosexuals.
soothsayer--
I private messaged you. Hope you don't mind the blog, and didn't take this ballot as a personal attack on yours. I was just taking the topic a different direction. I think deep thoughts, sometimes. I deliberately chose something as innocuous (sp.?), and universally considered Amoral as athletic ability, because I think I differ with most of society in that I DO think the process quite similar, and the comparison absolutely valid. The two have nothing to do with each other, but the organicprocess in "getting there" is, I will reiterate, similar. (imo) Obviously, some of our best athletes are homosexual, so a person can be both. At the same time, there are heterosexuals like myself who have trouble walking and chewing gum at the same time. lol Point is, to come to accept oneself for what one is, not to condemn or shame; if we want to change our brain function, I believe it's possible, but not without a lot of work, and it may be difficult or we may decide it's not worth it. That's ok, in my opinion, because it should be left up to the individual.
btw--I expected my comparison of the two to draw a lot more fire than it did.
by contragrain on Tue Aug 07, 07 5:57am [+]

About Us | Join Us | Privacy Policy |
© 2002-2008 BestAndWorst.com All Rights Reserved