search this site: search the web:
Don't support major websites, use a small ones like this one!

IS DRINKING OR DRUGGING TOGETHER SPIRITUAL? READ/THINK BEFORE YOU ANSWER!

user ballots

IS DRINKING OR DRUGGING TOGETHER SPIRITUAL? READ/THINK BEFORE YOU ANSWER!


[+] serious ballot by contragrain
ACTIVE Sat Aug 25, 07 - Sun Aug 24, 08

This is not necessarily about the persons who drink or drug excessively; although since those behaviours are so pervasive in our western cultures these folks are certainly not excluded from this discussion, and will be discussed here in the description. It is also NOT intended to be discussed as a MORAL issue.

First it may be necessary to think through exactly what spirituality itself involves. Native Americans met together in Sweat Lodges and sometimes used peyote for religious purposes. Actually, peyote (mescaline) is still legally permissable for this purpose; but, only on the Indian Reservations.

Additionally, in a letter from Swiss Psych. M.D. Carl Jung (b. 26 July 1875 d. 6 June 1961) to Alcoholics Anonymous co-founder Bill Wilson, he addresses the non-sectarian universal spiritual aspect of the 12 step program as it relates to alcohol and alcoholism. In that letter he specifies that it is no accident that alcohol is commonly referred to as spirits, and that the spirituality has, for some folks ie. the ones with whom Wilson was working, turned negative. He uses a latin phrase spiritus contra spiritum to emphasize the point of how the 12 steps tackle the alcoholism issue.
So, was the Old West practice of smoking the "peace pipe" to seal the deal spiritual?
Is having a cocktail or two with your buddies after work spiritual?
What about passing around a joint?
Is spirituality always positive?
Some people may feel they've had very positive experiences doing these very things. Others may have a quite opposing view of the social behaviours to which I refer.
I have heard people--in my 44+ years of travelling around our Sun--joke about getting high and "getting closer to God." But, is there any aspect of that statement with merit?
I'm sure to get some pranksters on this ballot; but, I'm looking for the serious answer.
Is calling beer, wine, whiskey, gin, vodka, tequila, rum etc. spirits a misnomer? What do you think? Spiritus Contra Spiritum, or not?

Yes, drugs are spiritual, we look to them for answers.
No, drugs are not spiritual.
Hmm... I never thought of it this way... may be...
this is way too wierd for me to consider
other, see comment

Ballot #117349 : SEE RESULTS

Comment:

show your vote with comment?

v 2.0 © BESTANDWORST.COM
smile bank:










similiar ballots:
112377. Can Mythological Figures have a spiritual essence?
117348. Is eating spiritual? How often do you eat with family and friends?
32426. If there are so many creative, intelligent and spiritual people in this world, why is it that it's only liars, crooks, thieves and murders in power?
94607. Drinking and posting
15653. Waking up next to a stranger after drinking...
55532. The B&W Irish Drinking Song!
106879. what bottled water am I drinking?
125333. What is the legal drinking age on the Isle of Man?
129560. Is the U.S legal drinking age too high?
52035. Who said 'Work is the curse of the drinking classes'?


COMMENTS:
I'll answer your question soon (although you have chopped up parts of his letter). I would recommend answering this ballot ballot #85585 first. Of course, voting can be anonymous.
by FiddleFaddleOnLSD on Sun Aug 26, 07 5:07am [+]

Let me see if this works.
by FiddleFaddleOnLSD on Sun Aug 26, 07 5:14am [+]

I'll go with Dr. Jung and Mr. Wilson on this one.
by FiddleFaddleOnLSD on Sun Aug 26, 07 5:17am [+]

Voted : other, see comment
Can't really say. Don't do either.
by Truthseeker013 on Sun Aug 26, 07 5:27am [+]

Voted : other, see comment
humans seek an expanded consciousness. right or wrong - drugs and alcohol obviously alter consciousness. is there any benefit to consciousness altered in this way? I suppose that depends on the individual. In our society - it appears that these substances are mostly abused and the results are not pretty, to the say the least. However, intoxication under certain circumstances can relax or stimulate the mind and allow it to wander into areas that might not otherwise be discovered. That is not necessarily a bad thing, regardless of our culturally learned distaste or perhaps mistrust of mind-altering substances.
by lightreaper on Sun Aug 26, 07 6:59am [+]

Voted : Yes, drugs are spiritual, we look to them for answers.
Thanks FF, Truth, Lightreaper. And thanks FF for the letter. Wow, didn't know anyone had a copy of it handy on their computer. I just realized that Jung apparently wrote that letter 6 months before he died. He was a great man.

Lightreaper,
Well stated: thank you for bringing the conversation back to center, nice level headed answer, too. Karma forthcoming. I definitely feel this to be an area where we must be ever vigilant in seeking balance, and while there are several references against strong drink in ancient literature, one writer balanced his admonitions with Proverbs 31:6-7. Excuse the example, but please understand that I only speak and give examples from that with which I have experience. It is not to elevate one religion/cultural tradition over another. Is it any wonder that in lots of ancient cultures, the "medicine man/woman" was also the "spiritual leader?"
by contragrain on Sun Aug 26, 07 8:14am [+]

Voted : No, drugs are not spiritual.
Mind altering substances can be calming, "emboldening", inhancing (your thought process), or the exact opposite...but they all make you more receptive of feelings or thoughts both positive or negative...I believe it's no realistic to think you can "connect" with your "higher power" if you are "high"...It reminds me of drug induced murders when the perpetrator(s) declares "God told me to do it"...
by thesoothsayer on Sun Aug 26, 07 10:12am [+]

^soothsayer, I sympathize with your comment. I also think that possibly the drug (be it alcohol, or some other substance) may actually becomethe higher power for some.
by contragrain on Sun Aug 26, 07 10:59am [+]

^you have captured the essence of alcoholism and drug addiction with that statement.
by FiddleFaddleOnLSD on Sun Aug 26, 07 3:40pm [+]

About Us | Join Us | Privacy Policy |
© 2002-2008 BestAndWorst.com All Rights Reserved