search this site: search the web:
Report due? School work? boss yelling at you? Shirking is good for the soul. Play at Bestandworst.com!

U.K WANTS TO DENY HEALTH COVERAGE TO CERTAIN PEOPLE

user ballots

U.K WANTS TO DENY HEALTH COVERAGE TO CERTAIN PEOPLE


[+] serious ballot by Kev24
created Tue Sep 04, 07

according to a newspaper article --


Patients who refuse to change their unhealthy lifestyles should not be treated by the NHS, the Conservatives said today.

In a bid to ease spiralling levels of obesity and other health concerns, a Tory panel said certain treatments should be denied to patients who refuse to co-operate with health professionals and live healthier lifestyles.

And those who do manage to improve their general health by losing weight and quitting smoking, for example, would receive "Health Miles" cards.

Points earned could then be used to pay for health-related products such as gym membership and fresh vegetables.

The aim is a shift in the NHS towards preventing disease and ill-health rather than having to treat it.

The proposal was one of a raft of measures suggested in a review of public services, ordered by David Cameron.

The 200-page study, entitled Restoring Pride in Our Public Services, was carried out by the Conservative public services improvement policy group's review co-chaired by former health secretary Stephen Dorrell and leading educationalist Baroness Perry.

"It is inconsistent with the concept of the responsible citizen to imagine that it is realistic for citizens, having paid their taxes, to expect that the state will underwrite the health implications of any lifestyle decision they choose to make," the report states.


is this the right direction? would you propose a similar plan in the united states?

yes i like this plan
no i don't like this plan


Ballot #117536 : SEE RESULTS

Comment:

show your vote with comment?

v 2.0 © BESTANDWORST.COM
smile bank:









similiar ballots:
75092. What percentage of Americans would support universal health care coverage, even if it meant raising taxes?
14811. Why do some people try to deny that US astronauts landed on the moon?
70069. If people needed a license to act in a movie or on TV, and you were in charge of granting said licenses, who would you deny a license to?
112799. What portion of people without health insurance are in working families?
47683. How can a capitalist society have a health-care system that focuses more on people than money?
75433. Is it ok to have compassion for people whose intentional bad health choices have caused them major problems?
74824. Is it hypocritical for the President and Congress to be against universal, national health care for the American people?
74663. Historically plagues have killed more people than large fires, so why are our fire departments federally funded but not our health care?
112333. Should I have the right to deny the holocaust ever happened?
114117. How much coverage is enough?


COMMENTS:
Voted : no i don't like this plan
Call-me-Dave Cameron can rarely not shoot himself in the foot. It's an idiot idea from a 'trendy' fool
by Bongo on Tue Sep 04, 07 11:23am [+]

Actually, I think it has its merits. We are told about the harm of unhealthy lifestyles. We are told about the rewards we can give ourselves by adopting healthy lifestyles. But we are never presented with an outside reward, one given to us by someone else. Animals (humans included) respond very favorably to other-generated rewards. I think this could have a positive affect if not misapplied. The controllers of this system would have to make exceptions for those suffering from genetically predisposed conditions that mimic those caused by unhealthy lifestyles, etc., etc. The exceptions could bog down the whole thing. The application of this concept would have to very well orchestrated.
by forgetmenot on Tue Sep 04, 07 12:02pm [+]

Voted : no i don't like this plan
But, it is the only way free health care can survive. Simple economics will prevent some people - due to age, weight, existing health conditions, et c - getting health care. Who will decide if a 50-year-old diabetic can have a heart bypass ? Who will decide if a 65-year-old tennis playing non-diabetic gets the bypass ? Who gets the kidney ? Who gets preventative medicine ?
by Black_Lava on Tue Sep 04, 07 2:57pm [+]

^ probably right. i for one don't like the plan either cuz there are always exceptions. and we all now bureaucrats can't handle exceptions. man, they're cut throat in the u.k. hmmm. 023
by Kev24 on Tue Sep 04, 07 3:37pm [+]

About Us | Join Us | Privacy Policy |
© 2002-2008 BestAndWorst.com All Rights Reserved