search this site: search the web:
Look, there's no advertisement anywhere! isn't that nice?

BOOK SAYS JUSTICE SOUTER WAS GOING TO RESIGN AFTER BUSH V. GORE ELECTION

user ballots

BOOK SAYS JUSTICE SOUTER WAS GOING TO RESIGN AFTER BUSH V. GORE ELECTION


[+] ballot by Kev24
created Tue Sep 04, 07

According to Jeffrey Toobin’s new book on the Supreme Court, Justice David Souter nearly resigned in the wake of Bush v. Gore, so distraught was he over the decision that effectively ended the Florida recount and installed George W. Bush as president.

In “The Nine,” which goes on sale Sept. 18, Toobin writes that while the other justices tried to put the case behind them, “David Souter alone was shattered,” at times weeping when he thought of the case. “For many months, it was not at all clear whether he would remain as a justice,” Toobin continues. “That the Court met in a city he loathed made the decision even harder. At the urging of a handful of close friends, he decided to stay on, but his attitude toward the Court was never the same.”


note the word installed. do you think he was racked with guilt over knowing the dark days we faced under bush?

should he have resigned and if so, why. if you think not, why not.

yes, he should have resigned
no, he helped to install bush and he suffers the same fate we are
No, and he didn't help install Bush


Ballot #117537 : SEE RESULTS

Comment:

show your vote with comment?

v 2.0 © BESTANDWORST.COM
smile bank:









similiar ballots:
93416. LIBERALS: If Bush offered to resign on the condition you drink one quart of the following (in SIX MINUTES OR LESS) on live TV, which would you choose?
76704. If Karl Rove is revealed to be the person who leaked the name of CIA agent, Valerie Plame, to the press, should he resign from the Bush White House?
125624. Bush Justice Department Lets Corporations Off The Hook!
127398. NEWS STORY: Bush Justice Department Weeds Out Liberals.
118409. What was the name of the book President Bush was reading on 9/11?
113017. What's a good name for a Comic Book about the Bush Administration?
102751. Ed Asner co-authors must-read book about the evils of the Bush regime.
1209. Will Bush win the next election?
57368. Which issue won Bush the 2004 election?
57464. Are you glad that Bush had won the 2004 election?


COMMENTS:
Voted : No, and he didn't help install Bush
I thought he voted against the majority decision. Gore v. Bush was one of the few times the Rehnquist wing of the Court voted for the Equal Protection clause.
by skylab on Tue Sep 04, 07 10:33am [+]

^ so explain. are you certain he voted against the decision? be more clear with your choice -- no he should not have resigned?

do some research and find out if you're correct that he did not vote to install bush. maybe his thoughts of resignation were because he was so aghast at the decision? details man! details!
by Kev24 on Tue Sep 04, 07 10:57am [+]

apparently he voted against the installation of bush --

Although appointed by a Republican president, and thus expected to be conservative (see Segal-Cover score), he is usually associated with the liberal wing of the Court. He dissented from the conservative majority in Bush v. Gore election of 2000.

so he i guess his thoughts of resigning because he felt so strongly that the court made the wrong decision?
by Kev24 on Tue Sep 04, 07 11:00am [+]

^Probably. I think he went along with the Equal Protection argument at first, but voted against stopping the recount.
by skylab on Tue Sep 04, 07 1:20pm [+]

^ sounds like he's done alot of second guessing about the whole thing. i also imagine that if he even thought of resigning, it must have been a pretty bad situation among the justices.
by Kev24 on Tue Sep 04, 07 8:21pm [+]

About Us | Join Us | Privacy Policy |
© 2002-2008 BestAndWorst.com All Rights Reserved