MEDIA CONTROLLED BY GOVERNMENT?

user ballots

MEDIA CONTROLLED BY GOVERNMENT?


[+] serious ballot by Kev24
ACTIVE Wed Sep 12, 07 - Sat Sep 15, 07

this is follow up to a previous ballot on government control of the news media.

some people believe that somehow the american government and perhaps other governments control the news media.

how? it's virtually impossible in most countries. even in china their government finds it's a losing battle.

even if a government tried to control the meida, in an open society, they could never succeed. in a country like the united states, there is a massive foreign press corp. major cities like washington d.c, nyc, los angeles, chicago, etc. have foreign press offices. so wouldn't that mean that the government would control them?

then there's foreign news programs on television. you can get foreign news from almost every country -- china, russia, the uk, italy, poland, australia. you name it.

what about the internet? no on controls that sucker. you can go to any foreign news site and sites like drudgereport link directly to forein press.

what about reuters for example. it's a major news service and newsflash -- it's not even american! so if you believed the u.s government controlled the news, how do you explain away all of this?

if the government controlled the news, you'd never read or here anything bad about the government. ha! that's all we do hear.

political allegiance. so how would, lets say, a republican administration control news media if that news organization is more liberal. or vice versa.

next question -- for those that believe that absurd conspiracy theory, answer the question of which part of the goverment controls the news? our government is huge. so which agency controls it and under whose direction?

if you can explain away what i show here, have at it. but i'll tell you, there is so much news flowing into this country every hour, there is no way the goverment could control it. no goverment can.

of course it's absurd to believe the government controls the news
wai! i am pre-programmed to believe stupid conspiracy theories!
i'll comment below

Ballot #118318 : SEE RESULTS

Comment:

show your vote with comment?

v 2.0 © BESTANDWORST.COM
smile bank:









similiar ballots:
118313. American Media : Controlled by government?
51725. Are Americans intrinsically controlled by the media?
76256. US Citizens -- Government Controlled Fear !
96460. Should Government determine what the Media reports?
12797. Is American media forced to brainwash its own people by their government
37435. Is it just a coincidence that once suspicions arose about the Nick Berg video, the government and media immediately stopped talking about it?
61446. Why is it that when CBS, a neutral media source, makes an honest mistake about George W. Bush, it's because "the media is liberal" ...
113100. Proof that America is really controlled by "big business"
122274. Would you rather fail at life or be totally controlled by someone else?
45363. Do you think that we are living in a World of Controlled Economic Slavery?


COMMENTS:
Voted : of course it's absurd to believe the government controls the news
But I'm sure Valerie Plame knows they try, on occasion.
by skylab on Wed Sep 12, 07 6:29pm [+]

i read these same arguments on here and from what i read no one's ever given evidence of this supposed control
by Kev24 on Wed Sep 12, 07 7:16pm [+]

I wouldn't say that the government runs the media but rather that they both belong to the same owner - corporations with special interests.
by robotthinker on Wed Sep 12, 07 8:15pm [+]

Voted : of course it's absurd to believe the government controls the news
Wake up, folks.

Yikes! Another fun conspiracy afoot.

MAG_eye
by Black_Lava on Thu Sep 13, 07 2:02am [+]

Voted : of course it's absurd to believe the government controls the news
^ What skylab said.

The Guv'mint *can*, however, *shape* things.
by Truthseeker013 on Thu Sep 13, 07 5:51am [+]

it's money.
by Jyl on Thu Sep 13, 07 7:51am [+]

Can I comment?
by aya on Thu Sep 13, 07 9:14am [+]

So now I can comment? I tried comment before, and it wouldn't let me. Anyway, I wouldn't say government has overt control, but heavily influences. CBC here is influenced by the PM. Is there anything to suggest that say, CNN or Fox isn't heavily influenced by the government. I would say corporations are a bigger problem. Fox, for example, and the Izzy Asper family in Canada controls Global, and many other papers in Canada, such as the National Post. Asper been openly biased about how stupid Canadians are, and how much he, and Conrad Black are for censorship. Taht is why readership for their papers went down
by aya on Thu Sep 13, 07 9:18am [+]

"what about the internet? no on controls that sucker. you can go to any foreign news site and sites like drudgereport link directly to forein press"

Actually, Google has been known to be mired in controversy regarding censorship. They've been blasted for censorship in China, and there is nothing to suggest that Google wouldn't do the same here.
by aya on Thu Sep 13, 07 9:19am [+]

I should also point out, that, the US government does have an inordinate amount of influence over the internet. For example, the US feds have a master database over top level domains. In 2005, the US government vetoed .xxx as a district for pornographers, which is something no other government in the world has the power to do. So this suggests a heavy influence.
by aya on Thu Sep 13, 07 9:29am [+]

No government should have such control over the internet, as it suggests the Internet has monopolistic control that could be detrimental to free speech
by aya on Thu Sep 13, 07 9:31am [+]

Voted : i'll comment below
Ever hear of a little group called the FCC? Government doesn't control all media, but don't think they try to control it as much as they can.
by _Beelzebubba on Thu Sep 13, 07 9:38am [+]

Voted : of course it's absurd to believe the government controls the news
a free press is prerequisite in a free society if you wish to have a means to "keep an eye" on what your government is up to...while I agree it is impossible to control the media as a whole, there are "unsavory" characters bent on purchasing "key" elements of the "press/media" with the intent of presenting the news in a light which may favor certain individuals in power, or paint and label others as undesireable...the younger generations are far more likly to look at all the news from many different sources than older people with fixed habits and are unwilling to embrace or even give many of the newer services the credit they deserve...what the Government does do and do well, is to set the tone on what we think and talk about...but not the conclusions we may draw...a good example is all the hoopla that comes before the President is scheduled to may a speech, all the second quessing and commentary that goes on to the point of "ad nauseam"...
by thesoothsayer on Thu Sep 13, 07 10:12pm [+]






About Us | Join Us | Privacy Policy | Contact
© 2002-2008 BestAndWorst.com All Rights Reserved