WAS THIS A FAIR PUNISHMENT FOR A LITTLE BOY?

user ballots

WAS THIS A FAIR PUNISHMENT FOR A LITTLE BOY?


[+] serious ballot by mojo
ACTIVE Thu Apr 03, 08 - Wed Jul 02, 08

In his seven years, Randy Castro has been an aspiring soccer player, an accomplished Lego architect and a Royal Ranger at his Pentecostal church. He also, according to his elementary school record, sexually harassed a first-grade classmate.

During recess at his Woodbridge school one day in November, when he was 6, he said, he smacked the classmate's bottom. The girl told the teacher. The teacher took Randy to the principal, who told him such behavior was inappropriate. School officials wrote an incident report calling it "Sexual Touching Against Student, Offensive," which will remain on his student record permanently.

Then, as Randy sat in the principal's office, they called the police.

"I thought they were going to take me to prison," Randy said recently. "I was scared."

I don't know about you, but when I was in the first grade, a good telling-off by the teacher was adequate punishment for being naughty. I guess these people don't trust their own measures of discipline?? IMO, it was the little BOY who was abused.

(Story from The Washington Post, April 3, 2008.)

No, that's crazy.
Yes, he sexually harassed the girl.
He needs some time in Stir.
The teacher needs a good smack in the ass.
All the School Officials need a smack in the *ss
Zero tolerance does not mean Zero Good Judgment.


Ballot #125289 : SEE RESULTS

Comment:

show your vote with comment?

v 2.0 © BESTANDWORST.COM
smile bank:









similiar ballots:
117123. What would be a fair punishment for Michael Vick?
31403. What was the worst PUNISHMENT you've ever gotten when you were a kid?
65040. what punishment should be given to this child?
69470. Reward and Punishment
72383. Racism or just punishment?
72808. YOu know when people say, that will be more punishment?
86719. What do you think this guys punishment should be?
92004. McKinney: What should her punishment be?
116183. Crime and Punishment
122654. Collective Punishment


COMMENTS:
Voted : No, that's crazy.
Scare tactics are B.S.
by ThisIsNate on Thu Apr 03, 08 6:49am [+]

Voted : The teacher needs a good smack in the ass.
Since when was a smack on the butt cheek considered sexual? Jocks do it to each other all the time. 017
by _Beelzebubba on Thu Apr 03, 08 6:51am [+]

OOPS! "in the ass" MAG_rofl

I meant "on the ass". wink

(what was I thinking?)
by _Beelzebubba on Thu Apr 03, 08 6:52am [+]

Voted : No, that's crazy.
of course. we live in a victim's world. one little thing happens and all of a sudden everyone's on the bandwagon freaking out and over reacting. tools. check out the news. one incident no matter how remote and no matter how astronomically high the odds are that it could happen again and there's some dork congress person talking about passing a law. the worlds gone mad. mad i tell you! 109
by Kev24 on Thu Apr 03, 08 7:29am [+]

exactly bubba. imagine if i cried harassment every time you poked me in the ass?
by Kev24 on Thu Apr 03, 08 7:31am [+]

Voted : The teacher needs a good smack in the ass.
We live in strange times. His only crime was being a Royal Ranger at his Pentecostal church.

You know, the more I think about it, the more I think he should have sent up the river.
by elvislennon on Thu Apr 03, 08 7:51am [+]

Voted : All the School Officials need a smack in the *ss
There seems to be a shortage of common sense going around these days...
by thesoothsayer on Thu Apr 03, 08 7:58am [+]

Voted : All the School Officials need a smack in the *ss
I just got here.

I'll be leaving now...

Well, after I say this.

Hasn't anyone there ever heard of sitting down and talking?
by Truthseeker013 on Thu Apr 03, 08 8:14am [+]

Voted : All the School Officials need a smack in the *ss
for stupidity.
by skylab on Thu Apr 03, 08 8:49am [+]

Voted : Yes, he sexually harassed the girl.
definitely.

one, the kid should have been educated at home about appropriate behavior. two, his "record" will reflect at what age this happened, so I doubt anyone would label him a molestor/predator, unless he repeats the behavior.

re: calling the police, I think they were just covering their own butts, as long as the kid wasn't taken to jail, I don't see any harm.


I bet he won't do THAT again.
by LCD on Thu Apr 03, 08 9:29am [+]

"we live in a victim's world.... blah blah"

I bet you would feel differently when you are the victim.
by LCD on Thu Apr 03, 08 9:32am [+]

so lcd you think a 6 year old kid is really capable of sexual harassment? it was one instance. ever think that in his mind it was like spanking? you know sort of like how some parents spank or say they'll spank. i seriously doubt he had anything sexual on his mind.

absurd to think he did.
by Kev24 on Thu Apr 03, 08 9:32am [+]

"we live in a victim's world.... blah blah"

I bet you would feel differently when you are the victim.
by LCD on Thu Apr 03, 08 9:32am


oh relax. you have your opinion and i have mind. snot ass.
by Kev24 on Thu Apr 03, 08 9:33am [+]

yeah and a guy like you thinks 6 year olds are sexually harassing each other. what does that say about your mind. 028
by Kev24 on Thu Apr 03, 08 9:34am [+]

" oh relax. you have your opinion and i have mind. snot ass."

typical reaction for you.

by LCD on Thu Apr 03, 08 9:55am [+]

blah blah"

I bet you would feel differently when you are the victim.
by LCD on Thu Apr 03, 08 9:32am


and this is a typical reaction for you. snotty and rude. you have your opinion and i have mine.

i am not going to get into this with you again. you have the issue not me. keep it going if you want but i'm not interested in this onn-going pissing contest with you. 058
by Kev24 on Thu Apr 03, 08 10:06am [+]

hey do you remember the crap YOU pulled before you went on vacation?

don't get high and mighty with me.
by LCD on Thu Apr 03, 08 10:10am [+]

Voted : Zero tolerance does not mean Zero Good Judgment.
Just think of the stuff we did to each other when I was a kid. We'd all be doing hard time if they had policies like this back then. And yet most of us turned out OK, not "Traumatized" by our experiences.
I think it's great that schools are trying to teach kids to be kinder to each other now. In my own past, the attitude was more like "kids will be kids, there's nothing we can do about it." However, there has to be a better balance between ignoring immature behavior and criminalizing it. That's going to take some legal counter-actions by folks like this kid's parents.
by UncleRandy on Thu Apr 03, 08 11:15am [+]

A little boy pulled my pants down in the first grade. I was embarrassed. I got over it. I don't understand what the big deal is. These people are SIX YEARS OLD, for godsakes!
by mojo on Thu Apr 03, 08 12:50pm [+]

Voted : No, that's crazy.
More PC nonsense. He was only playing & fooling around as most 6 year old boys' would do. He is too young to even know about the sexual connotations of his action. Crazy.
by wildcard on Thu Apr 03, 08 1:10pm [+]

switcheroo: What if the girl had smacked the boy's bottom? Would the same rules apply?
by mojo on Thu Apr 03, 08 2:18pm [+]

I think it was a little too much. I think a harsh speech from the teacher or principal would have been enough. That's what they did when I was in school and everyone turned out fine.

I see what LCD's saying though. He should have been taught better at home before he acted out in school.
by Grumpy_Person on Thu Apr 03, 08 3:02pm [+]

the fact is a 6 year old boy or girl does not comprehend sexual harassment. first of all, harassment denotes a pattern. it is never a single event per se. it is a pattern. to even think a little boy has that mentality is sick. or a girl.
by Kev24 on Thu Apr 03, 08 3:02pm [+]

I see what LCD's saying though. He should have been taught better at home before he acted out in school.
by Grumpy_Person on Thu Apr 03, 08 3:02pm

he may have been. like i pointed out, spanking and child rearing are connected. how many parents say "you'll get a spanking if you don't behave." did anyone think that all this poor little boy had on his mind was a spanking? if we're that ready to hang out a 6 year old boy, my decision to move to europe is already made.
by Kev24 on Thu Apr 03, 08 3:05pm [+]

What's spanking have to do with it? You can teach a child without spanking them. If you instill values rather than instilling fear of punishment, you'll never have to worry about whether or not to spank.

As for sexual harassment from a 6 year old, most don't know the meaning of it, true. But there's some out there who have minds more dirty than we can imagine, thanks to their parents who thinks it's funny.

I dated a guy in highschool who's step father was like that. If his kids learned anything from him, they're probably in prison now for sexual assault.
by Grumpy_Person on Thu Apr 03, 08 5:09pm [+]

what does spanking have to do with it? probably more than sexual harassment. read the ballot again. this kid. this freaking 6 year old kid, "smacked" the other kid's behind. who in their right mind jumps to the conclusion that it was sexual harassment? two 6 year olds? come on.
by Kev24 on Thu Apr 03, 08 6:31pm [+]

I can't come to a conclusion either way because I don't know in what sort of context the kid "smacked" his classmate. All I know about this case is from what that article reported. He could have smacked her to be mean, or he could have smacked her because he sees his daddy do it to his momma when he's had too many beers. Whatever the cause, he should have been taught better.

Call it "sexual harassment" or not, but there are kids out there who engage in activities with sexual connotations, even though they hardly know what sex is. I've seen my share of them while working with kids. I even talked to a man one time who's foster child bent down in front of him after dinner one time and tried to unzip his zipper so she could perform oral sex. Why? Because the child had been taught and trained that way.

Yes, it's rare and we don't normally think of 6 year olds sexually harassing another person. But it does happen.
by Grumpy_Person on Thu Apr 03, 08 7:42pm [+]

i see your point grumps. its hard for me to think in those terms with a 6 year old. but you do have valid points.
by Kev24 on Thu Apr 03, 08 8:34pm [+]






About Us | Join Us | Privacy Policy | Contact
© 2002-2008 BestAndWorst.com All Rights Reserved