YOU ARE A JUDGE: ONE HALF OF A SIAMESE TWIN HAS COMITTED MURDER, THE OTHER ONE IS INNOCENT, THE TWINS ARE INSEPERABLE, WHAT WOULD BE YOUR SENTENCE?

user ballots

would you : ethics :

YOU ARE A JUDGE: ONE HALF OF A SIAMESE TWIN HAS COMITTED MURDER, THE OTHER ONE IS INNOCENT, THE TWINS ARE INSEPERABLE, WHAT WOULD BE YOUR SENTENCE?


[+] serious ballot by Preparation_H
created Sun Oct 10, 04

You couldn't give him/her a jail sentence because it would mean also locking up an innocent person, you couldn't excecute him/ser because the chances are that the other person would be killed too, plus they would have to have a corpse attatched to them for the rest of their life, so what would you do?

Hmmmm. Ask my Siamese Sistah what she would do...
both must be held responsible
tattoo 'murderer' on the killer's forehead
other (comment)
jail 'perks' for the innocent twin
The PC term is "conjoined twins", you fascist!
1 is a murderer and the other is an accomplice


Ballot #54559 : SEE RESULTS

Comment:

show your vote with comment?

v 1.5 © BESTANDWORST.COM
smile bank:









similiar ballots:
94977. American barbarians murder more innocent people.
94286. Did Robert Wagner and Christopher Walken murder Natalie Wood in 1981 and cover it up? You be the judge...
106280. Which set of twins are the bigger slags? The Bush Twins or the Olsen Twins?
70155. If you were to cut an apple pie in half, then cut the resulting half in half again and so fort, how many cuts would it take to reach the last atom?
95474. half full or half empty
126500. Albums in which the first half is drastically different from the 2nd half
125691. Are Half Black Half White Musician Better Than All Black Musicians?
53176. If a brick weighs a pound and half a brick. How much does half a brick weigh?
75103. If you were a twin..
103392. Do You Believe That Everyone Has A Twin Somewhere In The World?


COMMENTS:
Yes, I'd do LIFE with my Siamese Sistah. After all, what choice would I have? If I were a judge...? Tough call.
by xxxxxxxx on Sun Oct 10, 04 2:36pm [+]

so you'd be willing to go to jail for someone elses crime?
by Preparation_H on Sun Oct 10, 04 2:36pm [+]

My sentence would be...............
Oh bugger what are we gonna do about this!!!
ta da
ok ok im going
by xxxxxxxx on Sun Oct 10, 04 2:41pm [+]

We're on a very slippery slope with this one Prep! I think I would have to go with guilt by association! even if the other twin was not a willing participant in the crime, he/she is at the very least an accessory (no pun intended) before and after the fact...might beat the conspiracy part of the rap though! Thanks Prep now you're going to have me thinking about this one all day long! GOOD JOB! :)
by xxxxxxxx on Sun Oct 10, 04 2:44pm [+]

lol
by Preparation_H on Sun Oct 10, 04 2:48pm [+]

Prep: Yes, if I was conjoined to my Siamese Sistah and she was guilty guilty guilty, then I'd have to accept some of that guilt, only because I hadn't managed to persuade her not to do it. :)
by xxxxxxxx on Sun Oct 10, 04 3:01pm [+]

Great question, though. Karmically deserving...
by xxxxxxxx on Sun Oct 10, 04 3:02pm [+]

Well the other siamese twin is at fault as well. Since the other one is in half control of the body, he or she could of prevented the murder. They both would have to take the jailtime. Its very hard to believe that the other twin could be truly "innocent"
by xxxxxxxx on Sun Oct 10, 04 3:03pm [+]

not all the time, some of them control different limbs
by Preparation_H on Sun Oct 10, 04 3:11pm [+]

hmmmmm... knew I shouldnt have allowed guests on this ballot...
by Preparation_H on Sun Oct 10, 04 3:29pm [+]

you murder him and i`ll beat us up!!!
by xxxxxxxx on Sun Oct 10, 04 3:59pm [+]

this guy that tries to spoil ballots? does he really have nothing better to do. hes like an annoying fly that wont go away.
by xxxxxxxx on Sun Oct 10, 04 4:01pm [+]

Both must be held responsible. They are both present, therefore one would at the very least be an accomplice, after all, why didn't the other twin try to stop his half from doing it, or warn the victim?
by jappy on Sun Oct 10, 04 5:58pm [+]

Permanently mark the words 'murderer' on the killer's forehead somehow.
by nuckinfutz on Sun Oct 10, 04 6:35pm [+]

As the Judge, assuming you couldn't prove that the 'innocent' twin was guilty as well, perhaps unable physically to prevent the murder, I would order half of the jail cell to be reeeally comfortable and allow for conjugal visits for the innocent twin. The guilty twin would have to watch the visits, haha... and sleep on the brick pile half of the bed.

ZIG: Seein's how I have the BESTEST Siamese Sistah eva, I could not imagine putting her through that!!! But I'd do the same for ya! :)
by magdalenasdollar on Sun Oct 10, 04 8:19pm [+]

Very tough call, I'd say the whole body went to jail, but the one that didn't commit murder would be treated much better. The innocent one would sit down while the guilty one would do all the work, and the innocent one would get fed much more. And maybe they'd get occasional walks to restaurants, but the innocent one would get more outside privelages. All and all, they'd be in the same place, but the innocent one would be treated much better. That's my best answer...
by GS_NewWorldRuler on Sun Oct 10, 04 8:38pm [+]

This is where law school really pays off. This is what I'd do if I were the judge. I wouldn't give out any jail time, instead I'd make the guilty one wear a blindfold and earmuffs for a period of time. This way it is the same as if they were in jail except the innocent one would be free while the other one would have no sense or freedom.
by Liberal_Democrat on Sun Oct 10, 04 9:31pm [+]

Who is this Philly idiot talking about clowns and turds?
by xxxxxxxx on Mon Oct 11, 04 10:07am [+]

The innocent was not a participant. He was asleep when the other shot and killed someone, nad the other didn’t know about it.

However, I would give the guilty life and put him in the custody of the other.
by Guest User from [12.36.59.202] on Fri Jun 15, 07 8:59am [+]






About Us | Join Us | Privacy Policy | Contact
© 2002-2008 BestAndWorst.com All Rights Reserved