search this site: search the web:
100% User contributed and administered website.

ETHICS QUESTIONS RE: HUMAN ORGANS GROWN IN ANIMALS

user ballots

advice : ethics :

ETHICS QUESTIONS RE: HUMAN ORGANS GROWN IN ANIMALS


[+] serious ballot by Cathexis
created Mon Nov 22, 04

Experimentation is underway that has already successfully grown human organs in other animals (livers, hearts, brain cells, blood, etc.).

Biologists call the resulting hybrid animals Chimeras, after the mythical Greek creature with a lion's head, a goat's body and a serpent's tail. They are the products of experiments in which human stem cells were added to developing animal fetuses.

Chimeras are allowing scientists to watch, for the first time, how nascent human cells and organs mature and interact — not in the cold isolation of laboratory dishes but inside the bodies of living creatures. Some are already revealing deep secrets of human biology and pointing the way toward new medical treatments.

But with no federal guidelines in place, an awkward question hovers above the work: How human must a Chimera be before more stringent research rules should kick in?

No rules: They are always animals
Such research is unethical
If the change can be proven to enhance Sentience
If the change affects Behavioural characteristics
Fetuses should not be implanted in other species
when they can communicate
If they can grow me a penis as big as a horses'.


Ballot #59593 : SEE RESULTS

Comment:

show your vote with comment?

v 2.0 © BESTANDWORST.COM
smile bank:









similiar ballots:
111823. china's military is stealing and selling human organs
116671. Things animals think when they see a human
53188. Do we underestimate the capabilities of the minds of non-human animals?
102748. Speak all the human languages, or speak to all the animals?
44381. Which of your organs would they reject for transplantation?
4818. Should people be allowed to sell their organs?
63853. Do you think people should be paid for body organs?
131531. SHOULD WE KILL HEALTHY PEOPLE FOR THEIR ORGANS?
88595. If it were possible to accidentally shit out one of your vital organs, how different would hypochondriacs live their lives?
35623. How much do Morals and Ethics really matter


COMMENTS:
Chimerism becomes an especially sensitive topic when it involves growing entire human organs inside animals -- and it becomes even more sensitive when it deals in brain cells.

In experiments like those, some scientists assert that there is a non-trivial risk of conferring some significant aspects of humanity on the animal.
by Cathexis on Mon Nov 22, 04 10:19am [+]

well as usual human greed will prevail, its unethical for sure, but if I needed a new organ I would do whatever it takes to get one.
by ABC on Mon Nov 22, 04 10:22am [+]

The whole thing just sounds too Frankenstein freakish. When human beings start to mingle DNA like kids in a chemical factory without being able to accurately predict the results, it all becomes a bit nightmarish.
by xxxxxxxx on Mon Nov 22, 04 10:32am [+]

ick
by Qui_Qui on Mon Nov 22, 04 11:21am [+]

That is sick!
by Kiki on Mon Nov 22, 04 12:03pm [+]

It all goes back to science vs religion. I'm sure my opinion on the matter would differ with most people here so I'll just leave it there.
by Tadema on Mon Nov 22, 04 12:40pm [+]

Hey no, Tads... Speaketh your truth! Hopefully a difference of opinion would be respected by anyone here? And besides, I'm interested in what you think about it, too.
by xxxxxxxx on Mon Nov 22, 04 1:49pm [+]

Well, like many I see the cruel side to this issue but for me, if it helps to prolong human life, it is inevitable. This that were considered to be a crime against God centuries ago, are common place now. (heart transplants, etc) so providing they aren't in pain, I put human life before that of an animal and I know many people will not agree with that. If it comes down to a heart for my child and the life of a pig...badee badee badee..that's all folks. :)
by Tadema on Mon Nov 22, 04 2:05pm [+]

The are of particular interest for me is when it deals with growing human brain cells in animals.

In experiments like those, some scientists assert there is a non-trivial risk of conferring some significant aspects of humanity onto the animal.

In other words ... the animals become part human ... in a significant way.
by Cathexis on Mon Nov 22, 04 3:37pm [+]

Scary.

Still, the only standard we can apply to the matter is that of intelligence, that is to say evidence of such manifesting in the Chimeras. As much as we collectively want to invoke ethics in these matters, ethics will always be outweighed by what is judged to be the "greater need".
by Truthseeker013 on Wed Dec 01, 04 7:48pm [+]

About Us | Join Us | Privacy Policy |
© 2002-2008 BestAndWorst.com All Rights Reserved