search this site: search the web:
Welcome to our New Server! Stronger, faster, and now with Lutein!

IF A COP IS BEATING THE SHIT OUT OF ME AFTER I HAVE SURRENDERED, SHOULD I BE ALLOWED TO STRIKE BACK LEGALLY?

user ballots

ethics :

IF A COP IS BEATING THE SHIT OUT OF ME AFTER I HAVE SURRENDERED, SHOULD I BE ALLOWED TO STRIKE BACK LEGALLY?


[+] serious ballot by CletuSlackedJawYokel
created Wed May 04, 05

You occasionally see police officers trying to be HeMan and beat a suspect after he has been subdued. For all the individual knows, the cop isn't going to stop. You think people should be able to fight back and defend myself in this situation?

yes
no
Register to submit choices


Ballot #72817 : SEE RESULTS

Comment:
Register to submit comments
You may still vote without registration

show your vote with comment?

v 2.0 © BESTANDWORST.COM
smile bank:









similiar ballots:
41380. What is the best line in the movie Jay & Silent Bob Strike Back?
86272. It's 2008, and a Presidential candidate from the party opposite your beliefs runs on a platform of beating the living shit out of Paris Hilton.
94088. If the constitution allowed it would you vote to put Bill Clinton back in office?
38685. Britain has surrendered 3 of it's warships to the IRANIAN Navy. Should the U.S. save them again?
59331. Holy shit! Nuckinfutz was at a basketball game, and Ron Artest punched the shit out of him! What do you think of that?
77851. Which of the following can the FBI legally track?
119003. When you were first able to drink legally...
55854. Civil Unions for ALL Legally Recognized Couples?
70735. Legally Blind Golfer Scores Hole-In-One. Was it mainly luck or skill?
112947. Legal Minds : Scalper's Search Engine - Legally liable?


COMMENTS:
themselves*
by CletuSlackedJawYokel on Wed May 04, 05 3:57pm [+]

you can fight back, but chances are you will have extra charges brought against you, so I don't know the answer
by larrynelmira on Wed May 04, 05 4:00pm [+]

Not in my town you can't. Anyway the cops here are too smart to beat just anybody out in plain view of the public. That's what the waterfront is for.

by um__yeah on Wed May 04, 05 4:01pm [+]

I actually think I could have better phrased the question as "Are law enforcement personell held sufficiently accountable for their actions"? I mean, the Rodney King beat down, the countless events where suspects are filmed being struck while defenseless, the trigger-fingers out there who shoot way too prematurely, etc etc etc. How the hell did those LA cops get off, even if Rodney was a criminal?
by CletuSlackedJawYokel on Wed May 04, 05 4:12pm [+]

Rodney King kept getting back up
by RawIron on Wed May 04, 05 4:39pm [+]

Try being a cop for a couple of years.
by elvislennon on Wed May 04, 05 5:30pm [+]

I wonder how many times a suspect has said they surrendered, only to go into a violent frenzy as soon as the police let down their guard?
by ceejjj on Wed May 04, 05 5:45pm [+]

^But often times they are in cuffs while being beaten and restrained....
by CletuSlackedJawYokel on Wed May 04, 05 5:53pm [+]

Perhaps you should be allowed to fight back if being assualted by the police, but if you do fight, you are risking at least a more severe beating, and maybe worse.

What I think would be the best response is just try to survive it as best you can, and then "pass out" on the jail floor as soon as you are booked. This might give you evidence for a lawsuit later.

Or not.

Thanks for an interesting ballot.

by xxxxxxxx on Wed May 04, 05 6:02pm [+]

The stupidest thing you can do is resist arrest. Anyone who would even contemplate fighting back is either stupid or has never spent anytime on the street.
by elvislennon on Wed May 04, 05 6:50pm [+]

As a Black man, what you suggest is tantamount to suicide. If I'm in that sitch, I just lay there and take it.
by Truthseeker013 on Wed May 04, 05 8:33pm [+]

A good beating may be just what they need.Remember ,what doesn't kill you makes you stronger
by Quinn_the_Eskimo on Thu May 05, 05 12:13am [+]

If "subdued" then how would you fight back?

Cops don't just walk around wanting to kick the shit out of people. When suspects fight with cops, they have the sanctioned ability to bring whatever force THEY feel necessary.

I have been arrested a couple of times. Once I fought with them. They won the fight. When they were putting me in the car they "accidentally" banged my head against the door jamb. But I had broken one of the cops' nose. Later all charges were dropped against me because of the concussion they gave. In retrospect I don't think that was fair. I broke that cops nose and nothing happened to me and I had committed a crime already and that is why they were arresting me in the first place.

Ever since that time I have been respectful of police and they of me, even though I was arrested several more times.

In the US, in general, most police forces are good. With some exceptions you are pretty safe in uniformed cops hands.
by xxxxxxxx on Thu May 05, 05 1:12am [+]

I think we should be allowed to attack the cop even if they haven't hit us but as long as they're violating our rights. If you're being arrested for drug possession and you escape by knocking the cop out, justice has been served.
by thc2883 on Thu May 05, 05 10:04am [+]

Hell yes! When a cop start's doing that, then he/she is no longer a cop as far as I'm concerned.
by THX1138 on Thu May 12, 05 3:32pm [+]

About Us | Join Us | Privacy Policy |
© 2002-2009 BEST AND WORST dot com All Rights Reserved