user ballots
Login
Register
Add One
FAQ/Contact
Popular Ballots
Recent Popular
Recent Votes
Best
Worst
Yes or No
Choices
What If
Prediction
Advice
Would You
Crime
Recommend
Quiz
TV & Movie
Music & Radio
Political
Science
Sports
Relationship
Techonology
Culture
Philosophy
Religion
Ethics
History
Food & Health
Fashion & Beauty
Crime
FanBase
Discussion
Bug Report
|
COMMENTS:
Because a show of support for US servicemen would prove that they are not all evil butchers. This does not suit their agenda. I don't support the war, but still respect personnel in Iraq; not everyone feels the same way
A conspiracy?
by MO_ on Sun Jun 18, 06 10:00am
[+]
Perhaps they were unaware of the treatment the prisoners, you could always contact them and make them aware of it. As to your assertion of them being on a par with prisoners at gitmo, one difference strikes me right away... they have ;egal representatiopn and they have been charged with a crime. Two things the gitmo detainess have not had the right to. I am surprised that you would want to come to the defence of these soldiers , given your personal stance about serving in the forces.
"Sounds like worse than anything happening in gitmo (sic) (or at least on par to what people are complaining about)." Nonsense. Those individuaals haven't been held for over four years, without charges and without legal representation. And they're not being tortured. No comparison.
But thos emen are Marines, subject to the UCMJ for conduct unbecoming. I'm surprised that they let them out without the shackles. This is old news, in a sense.
^ Yes.
Zig: do you honestly think that would stop them? According to the geneva convention the people picked up in afghanistan have absolutely no legally defined rights, and somehow the ACLU manages to defend them. And from what I can see the military was going above and beyond what was necessary to restrain these guys, which is why they ultimately relented and reduced their security procedures. And as I recall, these people aren't guilty, not yet anyway.
As far as I know, herz, all US military detainees are under the sole jurisdiction of the UCMJ, as dictated by the Chain of Command. It may seem harsh, but military justice was always harsh, and in this case the ACLU have no redress, nor do said detainees - innocent or guilty.
|
|